PREVIOUS   CONTENTS  NEXT

 

Page 155
Chapter 20
Model Papers
Use the following research papers as guidelines as you prepare your own.

 

Page 157
Model # 1: Comics and History
Outline
Thesis: The development of comic books reflected the social situations of the 20th century.
I. 1930s: Comics offer escapism from the Depression.
A. Escapist fantasies fuel comic strips.
B. Comic strips compiled into books.
C. Golden Age of Comics began.
II. 1940–1945: Comics serve as American propaganda in World War II.
A. WW II brings escapism, reflected in comics.
B. Comics feature patriotic heroes fighting for American values.
III. 1946–1950: Comics languished.
A. The atomic bomb eclipsed superheroes' impact.
B. "Archie" comics become popular with America's teenagers.
C. Horror comics appear; become increasingly gory.
IV. 1950–1955: Comics fall prey to Congressional attack.
A. Congress meets to determine if juvenile delinquency caused by comics.
B. Comics Code Authority formed to censor objectionable material in comics.
V. 1956–1960s: Superheroes return to comics.
A. New superheroes mirror American quest for heroes.

 

Page 158
B. War comics show civilian side of conflict, reflecting America's conflicting feelings about the Vietnam War.
VI. 1970s: Comics again became relevant.
A. Comics focus on important issues in the 1970s.
B. Comics become more gritty and realistic.
VII. 1990s: Comics reflect modern concerns.
A. Comics keyed to pressing social issues.
B. Comics similar to TV and movies in themes and topics.

 

Page 159
Comics and History
During the 1930s, purveyors of popular culture offered escape to the American people. Their efforts served in part to ease people through the economic calamity of the Depression. Comic strips such as ''Tarzan,'' "Buck Rogers," and "Prince Valiant" served to transport the reader elsewhere--a jungle, a desert, a distant planet, the past or the future--where the action had no bearing on the grueling reality of the day. As the decade progressed, adventure strips grew in popularity, fueling escapist fantasies for the economically distressed [Savage 3].
The comic book industry began in the mid-1930s. Publisher M. C. "Max" Gaines thought that compiling a collection of newspaper comic strips in a magazine form would work well as a premium giveaway [Thompson 23]. So the first comic book was just that, reprints, given away with products ranging from soap to breakfast cereal to children's shoes. Other companies quickly saw the popularity of such magazines and very soon, all the usable strips were being reprinted and sold as books [Savage 4].
In 1934, Major Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson started his company by printing New Comics and New Fun Comics, using all new material. He hired Max Gaines to be in charge. In 1936, they started another new title, Detective Comics, the first comic book devoted to a single theme. These were precursors to the vaunted "golden age" of comic books.

 

Page 160
The so-called "Golden Age" of comics officially began in 1938. While looking for a lead feature to launch another new title, Gaines and his editors settled on a strip that had been created five years earlier and unsuccessfully offered as a newspaper strip by two teenagers from Cleveland, Jerry Seigel and Joe Shuster. The character could lift cars, leap over buildings, and bounce bullets off his chest. The new magazine was named Action Comics. The character was called Superman [Daniels 32].
Superman proved to be an overnight success. As quickly as they could, other publishers--and DC itself, as Gaines, company had come to be called--sought to make economic lightning strike again and again. Costumed heroes arrived by the busload, feeding the escapist public with fantastic adventures [Savage 17].
Not long before the second World War, impelled by world affairs and the public mood, the comic book industry created a number of "patriotic" heroes: Captain America, Fighting Yank, The Americommando, and even Uncle Sam, who began appearing in National Comics in July of 1940. This signaled the end of comic book escapism. As war became part of everyday life, comics became a vehicle for propaganda.
Military Comics was launched several months before the United States entered World War II, advertising "Stories of the Army and Navy." The leading hero was Blackhawk who, we learned in the first issue, was a Polish aviator whose family had been killed by Nazis. He waged aerial guerrilla warfare against Nazi Germany in his distinctive

 

Page 161
Blackhawk plane--which had a striking resemblance to a Grumman skyrocket [Goulart 181].
Comic books became a part of the Allied propaganda machine, emphasizing the need for a maximum war effort by portraying the enemy as a vast, inhuman evil. All variety of heroes, including Superman and Batman, were portrayed on covers promoting war bonds and punching out the "JapaNazis.". Additionally, hundreds of thousands of comics were shipped to Allied troops around the world [Savage 10]. The audience for comics grew to astounding proportions [Goulart 241].
After the war, however, interest in the super-heroes began to wane. The atomic bomb was so overwhelming that costumed strongmen no longer seemed "super" to the American public. As a result, the comics' publishers started looking for new genres that would sell. Crime comics, western comics, war comics, and romance comics all started appearing. Like post-war Americans, comics had entered an age of complacency.
MLJ Publications started a back-up feature about "America's Typical Teenager" ... a red-haired Romeo named Archie Andrews. Archie and his pals--Betty, Veronica, and Jughead--were America's stereotypical teenagers, sweet and carefree. They had typical 1950s concerns: finding dates, buying "cool" clothes, and getting Archie's jalopy to run. Archie eventually pushed all MLJ's superheroes off the stands, which showed how 1950s teens favored comics that reflected the lighthearted mood of their everyday lives.
At the same time, EC Publications (which Max Gaines had started after leaving DC and which was

 

Page 162
now being run by his son Bill) started grinding out horror comics [Daniels 79]. Clearly, they were catering to different audiences. With such titles as Tales from the Crypt and Weird Science, Bill Gaines and his crew set the industry scrambling in a new direction, one that eventually spawned a parental uproar and a Congressional investigation.
With each new rival publisher going for more and more gory material, it was an easy task for psychologist Fredric Wertham to blame all the ills of society on comic books. He gained notoriety and generated healthy sales of his book Seduction of the Innocent. Wertham's efforts spurred Congress to divert their attention briefly from Communism to the issue of juvenile delinquency. Congress viewed comics as a medium exclusively for children. Since the comics were very violent, they would therefore have to be altered to conform to Congress's narrow views of acceptable reading material [Daniels 83].
Congress's attempt to clamp down on comics reflects the general conservative attitude of the 1950s, the country's fear of "subversives" and strangers. Their "witch hunt" against comics is a variation of their ''witch hunt" against Communists.
In an attempt to forestall Congressional action and public backlash, the larger publishers banded together and formed the Comics Magazine Association, with a Comics Code for appropriate comic book material. Like the blacklisted "Communists," Gaines and his competitors were forced to abandon comics virtually overnight. Gaines himself was called before the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee during the aforementioned hearings on juvenile delinquency. Gaines did, how-

 

Page 163
ever, continue on the fringe of the business, publishing a highly successful comic book-turned-magazine to dodge the code: MAD [Daniels 85].
Comic books languished throughout the early and mid-50s until Julius Schwartz, an editor at DC in 1956, proposed bringing the superheroes back for another try. This was not a return to the escapism of the 1930s, though. These new heroes would be thoroughly moder--"more human," claimed the publishers. Schwartz revised and revamped DC's old lineup, including The Flash, Green Lantern, Hawkman, The Atom, and the Justice League of America [Crawford 326].
In part, these mythical heroes filled the need and desire for real heroes, a role filled by baseball players Joe DiMaggio and Jackie Robinson, movie stars John Wayne and Charlton Heston, and military figure Dwight David Eisenhower.
Meanwhile, over at Atlas (formerly Timely) Comics, publisher Martin Goodman saw the success of his rivals and suggested to his young editor that they should start publishing superhero comics as well. The editor, a longtime writer of comics for Timely/Atlas named Stan Lee, took a shot and created the Fantastic Four, Spider-Man, the Incredible Hulk, and the X-Men [Crawford 340].
It should be mentioned, however, that for many years these new superhero comics were not as reflective of American society as their predecessors had been. The early sixties saw almost as many new comic book characters as the 1940s had, but while 1940s heroes protected the homefront in World War II, 1960s heroes scarcely, if ever, mentioned Vietnam [Savage 66].

 

Page 164
As the Vietnam War escalated, the popularity of war comics decreased, with the notable exception of comics that showed the gritty, unglamorous side of war. The DC comic Enemy Ace, for example, described World War I from the vantage point of a German pilot, thus humanizing the enemy. The previous generation of war comics, in contrast, had portrayed war from the soldier's point of view. The Sergeant Rock stories continued this new trend, focusing much more on human relations than on the patriotic spirit of World War II comics. By the end of the Vietnam War, the only war comic left was Sgt. Rock. But like any other old soldier, he eventually faded away.
In the early 1970s, DC had another brief period of historical relevance as the new generation of writers combined journalism with fiction. "Not fact, not current events presented in panel art, but fantasy rooted in the issues of the day," said Denny O'Neil, a comic author of that time, describing these new comics. These angry issues dealt with racism, overpopulation, pollution, and drug addiction. DC dramatized the drug abuse problem in an unusual and unprecedented way by showing Green Arrow's heretofore clean-cut boy sidekick Speedy turning into a heroin addict. These comics clearly show America's concern with the pressing social issues of the day. While DC was showered with praise for this bold move, declining sales caused Schwartz to announce in 1973, "Relevance is dead." [Goulart 297]
Also in the 1970s, the comic book industry became aware that their audience was changing. Instead of losing all its readers at age 14 (as

 

Page 165
had been the pattern in the past), they were staying on, looking for more diverse and challenging material. Coupled with the growth of a direct market, in which the publishers could supply books directly to specialized comic book shops, and the utilization of new printing technologies, the industry went through its largest expansion, with record numbers of titles being produced every month [Goulart 307]. As America became more open about previously taboo subjects--sex and violence--comics became much more gritty and realistic.
Today's comics deal with important issues on a new level. Timely/Atlas, now called Marvel Comics, dealt with racism in a whole new way. After they established that their heroes were "Mutants," they ran a crossover series about the mutant hate groups that had sprung up in the comic-book world. Cries of "Die Mutie scum!" echoed through the comics with an almost Ku Klux Klan-worthy fervor [Goulart 332].
A new generation of horror comics, many produced by fans-turned-professionals from England, began to appear, aimed at an adult audience. Far more graphic than those of the 1950s, but also with far more complex storylines, these books in particular have led former readers back into the comic book fold. This echoes the way television and movies have changed to fit the public's taste over the past forty years [Goulart 344]. DC's Vertigo line targets the same audience as the TV show Buffy the Vampire Slayer.
Over the years, as society as changed, so have comics. Now, as the world becomes increasingly computerized, comic companies have Web pages. In

 

Page 166
addition, most of the larger comic companies are coloring on computer rather than by hand. As the world continues to change, the comic book industry must continue to adapt to fit the needs and wants of its audience if it is to survive.

 

Page 167
Works Cited
Crawford, Hubert H. Crawford's Encyclopedia of Comic Books. Middle Village, N.Y.: Comicade Enterprises, 1978.
Daniels, Les. COMIX: A History of Comic Books in America. New York: Bonanza Books, 1971.
Goulart, Ron. Great History of Comic Books. Chicago, Ill.: Contemporary Books, Inc., 1986.
Savage, William W. Comic Books and America, 1945–1954. Oklahoma: University of Oklahoma Press, 1990.
Thomson, Don. The Comic-Book Book. New Rochelle, N.Y.: Arlington House, 1973.

 

Page 168
Model #2: Prozac: Salvation or Damnation?
Outline
Thesis: Prozac should be used with great care.
I. Introduction
A. Anecdotal opening
B. Thesis
II. Background
A. How Prozac works
B. Statistics on sale and use
III. Advantages of Prozac (opposition side)
A. Emotional calm
B. Fewer side effects than other antidepressants
C. Helps many patients
IV. Disadvantages of Prozac (writer's side)
A. Side effects may outweigh advantages
1. Thoughts of suicide
2. Emotional void
3. Decreased libido
4. Personality changes
5. May accelerate tumor growth
6. Other side effects
B. May be overprescribed
C. Provides only a quick fix
V. Conclusion

 

Page 169
Prozac: Salvation or Damnation?
Melissa Ryder was suffering from depression. To relieve her symptoms, her doctor prescribed Prozac. ''After only six days on Prozac, I was in far worse shape than I had ever been before," she said in an interview. Her bizarre side effects included dreams of bouncing off walls, uncontrollable trembling, urges to stab herself, and thoughts of killing her children. Melissa Ryder is no longer using Prozac and her condition has improved greatly [Bowe 42].
Despite Prozac's tremendous global popularity, some serious issues are being raised about its negative effects. Prozac's many side effects can do more damage than the makers of the drug could have ever imagined, as Melissa Ryder's case illustrates. While Prozac can help some people suffering from depression and other mental disorders, it should be used only with great care.
Prozac, also known by its chemical name Fluoxtine, is the first "designer drug" created expressly to treat depression by altering the biochemistry of only one system in the brain. Prozac interferes with the reabsorption process of serotonin going into the brain. It slows down the uptake of serotonin, making it more available to the brain when needed [Brown 153].
In 1993, the sale of Prozac totaled $1.2 billion. A one month's supply of the drug retails for approximately $63. Toward the end of the 1993, it was estimated that ten million people worldwide have taken Prozac [Breggin 47]. These figures show that Prozac must be helping many people.

 

Page 170
The drug clearly has some advantages in the treatment of depression. Doctors boast that Prozac affords some patients a consistent, calm feeling, unlike that achieved through other antidepressants that have less severe side effects than Prozac. According to science writer Claudia Bow, "Prozac happens to have fewer side effects because it alters one brain chemical (serotonin), while most other antidepressants affect many chemical systems in the brain" (44).
Speaking of her depression, Margaret London, an office manager in Manhattan, said, "Everything was gray and black. It was like being in a pit." Ms. London tried all the different kinds of antidepressants currently on the market, but only Prozac helped her. She said, "After being on Prozac, I began to realize that I no longer felt depressed and unhappy. I felt as if someone had whitewashed the world" [Bowe 42].
Although Prozac was beneficial to Margaret London, for many patients, Prozac's side effects greatly outweigh its benefits. Prozac's negative effects range from suicide to sexual dysfunction. Martin Teicher, a psychiatrist from Boston University, studied his patients on Prozac and concluded, "A significant percentage of Prozac users were thinking of stabbing themselves, turning on gas jets in their apartments and striking a match to blow themselves up" ["Open Verdict" 76]. Other psychiatrists have reported similar results. In September, 1989, a man taking Prozac shot twenty people and then killed himself. His doctor said that the man was not violent until he began taking Prozac. As a result of this incident, lawsuits

 

Page 171
amounting to hundreds of millions of dollars were filed against Eli Lilly, the company that sells Prozac ["Open Verdict" 76].
There are also complaints from people of feeling devoid of emotions while on Prozac. Dr. Randolph Catlin, a psychiatrist and chief of the mental health service at Harvard University, said, "Many of the students I treated with Prozac reported feeling split off from themselves. They felt as though they were not there any more." He added, "One wonders if these reports that you hear about patients acting aggressively while on Prozac might be cases where patients who are out of touch with their feelings act on their impulses, without having any feelings of guilt or concern" [Nichols 39].
Dulled or absent sexual response is a problem, too. It has been reported that some individuals on Prozac have a decreased libido or no desire for sexual activity. A United States study, published in The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry in April 1994, found that among 160 patients taking Prozac, 85 reported that their sexual desire or response diminished after using the drug [Nichols 36].
In addition, many patients on Prozac began to experience personality changes over time. A new study described at the annual meeting of the American Psychiatric Association suggests that Prozac alters aspects of personality as it relieves depression. Ron G. Goldman, a psychiatrist at Columbia University, believes that "Emotional and personality factors are intertwined in depression so it's not really surprising that some type of personality change would accompany improvement in this condition" [Bower 359]. Similarly, psychia-

 

Page 172
trist Peter Kramer, in his book Listening to Prozac, claims, ''Prozac offers nothing less than self transformation, turning self-doubts into confidence, increasing energy, even improving one's business acumen" [94].
In other cases, doctors have reported side effects of a more serious nature. Some scientists suspect that Prozac may accelerate tumor growth in people who already have cancer. In July 1992, the journal Cancer Research published a paper by a group of researchers showing that tumors in mice and rats seemed to grow faster when the animals were given Prozac [Nichols 40].
Prozac's other reported unpleasant side effects include jumpiness, nausea, insomnia, unwanted weight gain, headaches, and rapid heartbeat. "These symptoms have appeared in hundreds of thousands of patients," said Peter R. Breggin, MD, author of "Another View: Talking Back to Prozac." He adds, "When a doctor prescribes Prozac, it should be understood that these symptoms exist and that the risk is quite high. I believe that these warnings go unsaid as millions of people continue to take Prozac" [Brown 153–55].
Prozac is now the most frequently prescribed psychiatric medication. Physicians, mostly non-psychiatrists, are now writing almost one million prescriptions a month for the drug. "Many medical experts worry that some doctors are over-prescribing Prozac and using it to treat relatively trivial disorders" [Nichols 36].
In addition to overprescribing, there are problems with using Prozac as a quick-fix remedy. Psychiatrist Peter Breggin, cited earlier, said,

 

Page 173
"Too many doctors prescribe Prozac for minor depression or anxiety without talking to patients long enough to understand their problems. Too many patients look for pills to smooth out the inevitable ups and downs of everyday life" [Breggin 46-8]. Breggin argues, "In looking for the quick fix, too many psychiatrists have forgotten the importance of love, hope, and empathy in maintaining sanity." He adds, ''The main problem is Prozac is merely a stimulant that does not get to the root of depression and is dangerous when used improperly" [Breggin 80].
Over time, Prozac's dark side is becoming more apparent to the medical community and eventually to the general public. Maybe Prozac isn't the wonder drug of the 90s. While Prozac may help some people, it is not a miracle cure.

 

Page 174
Works Cited
Breggin, Peter. "Another View: Talking Back to Prozac." Psychology Today. July/August 1994: 46–81.
—— Talking Back to Prozac. New York: St. Martin's Press, 1994.
Brown, Avery. "Miracle Worker." People Weekly. November 15, 1993: 153–5.
Bowe, Claudia D. "Women and Depression: Are We Being Overdosed?" Redbook. March 1992: 42–4.
Bauer, Bruce. "Antidepressants May Alter Personality." Science News. June 4, 1994: 359.
Kramer, Peter. Listening to Prozac. New York: Penguin, 1993.
Nichols, Mark. "Questioning Prozac." McLean's. May 23, 1994: 36–41.
"Open Verdict: Prozac and Suicide." The Economist. January 19, 1991: 76.

 

Page 175
INDEX
A
Abstract, 135, 137
Audience, 18
Audiovisual sources, 56
B
Bias, 73, 76-78
Bibliography, 67-68
annotated, 71
working, 71
Bibliography cards, 67-72
Books in Print, 49
Boolean search, 64
Brainstorming, 12
C
Call numbers, 44
Card catalog, 47
reading an entry, 48
Clustering, 14
Common knowledge, 117-118
Computerized databases, 53
Cue words, 109-111
D
Dewey Decimal system, 44-47
Documentation, 83-84
guidelines, 85, 122
E
Editing checklist, 144
Electronic media, 59
Ellipsis, use of, 111-112
E-mail, 62
Endmatter, 137
Endnotes, 121-122
format, 124-126
guidelines, 124-125, 139
F
Footnotes, 121-122
format, 124-126, 139
guidelines, 124-125
Foreword, 135-137
Freewriting, 15
Frontmatter, 135
G
Glossary, 138
Government documents, 57
Guide to Reference Books, 49
H
"Hot" subjects, 18
I
Idea book, 14
Information, Please Almanac, 50
Internet, 59, 64-65, 79
Interviews, 55, 70
Introduction, 104-105
J
"Journalist's Questions," 15
K
Key words, 40, 60, 63
L
Library of Congress, 38, 59
Library of Congress system, 44, 46-47
Listing, 14
Loaded terms, 77
M
MLA Citation, 127
MLA Documentation, 119

PREVIOUS   CONTENTS  NEXT