The Builder Magazine 

November 1920 - Volume VI - Number 11 


A SUMMER RESORT FOR MASONS — MASONIC PARK, 
COLORADO 

BY BRO. J.L. ELICKER, COLORADO 

Thousands of tourists, hailing from nearly every State in the Union, annually visit the 
Rocky Mountains of Colorado. Among these are hundreds of Masons and their families. 
But very few of the latter have ever heard of this summer resort for Masons - Masonic 
Park, Colorado. 


This Park is under the management of the San Luis Valley Masonic Association, of which 
Brother Marshall H. Van Fleet, Alamosa, Colorado, is President, and Brother Jesse C. 
Wiley, Del Norte, Colorado, Secretary. Either of these brethren will be interested in 
hearing from any reader of THE BUILDER who may desire further information 
concerning the Park. 


Ideas go booming through the world louder than cannon. Thoughts are mightier than 
armies. Principles have achieved more victories than horsemen or chariots. - W.M. Paxton. 


THE MASONS of the rich San Luis Valley, Colorado, are enjoying something rather 
unique in the history of Masonry. It is a park devoted to summer- home puiposes, and the 
San Luis Valley Masons are sharing their summer vacational pleasures with other Masons. 


Many years ago, when it was decided to elevate Chicago out of the mud by raising its 
immense blocks up to grade, the young son of a poor mechanic, George M. Pullman by 
name, put in a bid for the big undertaking and secured the contract. 



While George was successfully completing this job, he was revolving in his mind his pet 
project of building a “sleeping car,” which would be adopted by all railroads, not so much, 
we take it, for financial emolument as for the service it would be to those who travel long 
distances. Accordingly, George fitted up two old cars on the Chicago & Alton road with 
berths, and soon found that they would be in demand. He then went to work on the 
principle that the better his cars, the greater would be the demand, and the greater the 
service rendered. After spending three years in Colorado gold mines, it is said that Mr. 
Pullman returned and built two cars which cost $18,000 each. Everybody laughed at what 
they called “Pullman's folly.” But George believed that whatever relieved the tediousness 
of long trips would meet with speedy approval; he had supreme faith in his idea, and 
risked his all in it. The result is well known. 


So it has ever been, and always will continue to be; the man with an idea which he puts 
into practical effect, contributing to the health, comfort and happiness of his fellowmen - 
the highest mission men and Masons can perform, and for which they will ever be held in 
high esteem. 


The germ of the steam engine, we are told, can be seen in the writings of the Greek 
philosophers, but it was not developed until more than two thousand years later. 


Likewise, the Supreme Architect of the Universe wrought His plans of marvelous beauty 
in Masonic Park ages before the fertile brain of Marshall H. Van Fleet, Deputy Grand 
Master of the Grand Lodge of Colorado, conceived the idea of providing a permanent 
summer home for Masons and their families among the picturesque Rocky Mountains - a 
home with an ideal climate, located over 8,000 feet above the level of the sea; a home 
where mosquito netting is unnecessary; where refreshing sleep is always possible, the days 
always delightful, and close communion with nature sweetest. 


When you step down off the platform of a Denver & Rio Grande passenger coach, or 
alight from your automobile within the limits of Masonic Park, the high mountains greet 
you on the east with their enticing wildness, while at the base of these mountains you 



behold the rippling waters of the Rio Grande River wherein the lively trout bids defiance 
to the angler. 


In this picture (Cut No. 1) you see these mountains in the distance and to your right. Their 
ascent is not so steep but that it is good exercise for a mountain hike in the early morning 
hours, followed by a cold bath in the river, if such be your custom. The novelty of a cold 
bath in the Rio Grande, at an altitude of 8,200 feet in water from the snow-capped peaks, 
may not be relishing at first, yet you will be suiprised at the good derived therefrom. 


This picture also conveys an idea of the stupendous rocks so familiar in this locality. Many 
a three-pound rainbow trout has been caught along these tracks. There is genuine sport and 
lasting benefit from such early-moming exercise out in the open. 


By looking to the northeast from the Denver & Rio Grande shed depot, this big rock (Cut 
No. 2) greets the eye. It has been named King Solomon's Rock. The gentleman seen at the 
base of this rock is Marshall H. Van Fleet, the man whose brain conceived such a camping 
ground for Masons and their families as is offered in this Masons' Park. This rock is 
estimated to be upwards of one hundred feet high. To the right of King Solomon's Rock is 
another rock on which nature has carved the picture of a man's face. This rock has been 
named George Washington. This is another good morning hike. You cross the bridge over 
the Rio Grande river, after which you have perhaps a climb of two hundred feet up to the 
base of these rocks. As you become accustomed to hiking, you may make longer trips. 


The big San Luis Valley, wherein is located this beautiful Masonic Park, is an empire by 
itself. It is from forty to fifty miles wide, by one hundred to one hundred twenty miles 
long, and is surrounded by high ranges of mountains, with an average elevation of about 
7,500 feet. In parts of this rich valley there are evidences of glacial formation. In other 
parts there are evidences of this valley once being the bed of a prehistoric lake. This is the 
opinion of scientists. It is noted for alfalfa, peas and hogs, the raising of which have netted 
many independent fortunes. Potatoes are also another product of this valley. 



There are seven lodges of Masons in the San Luis Valley, namely, Olive Branch No. 32 of 
Saguache, Alamosa No. 44 of Alamosa, Monte Vista No. 73 of Monte Vista, Amethyst 
No. 94 of Creede, Vulcan No. 103 of Hooper, Del Norte No. 106 of Del Norte, and 
Temple Gate No. 128 of Center. The present membership of these seven Masonic bodies 
totals, it is estimated, between six and seven hundred. With these Masonic brethren are 
associated an equal number of wives in the Order of Eastern Star, so that upwards of 
fifteen hundred are today interested in this Masonic Park. 


It was the custom of these San Luis Valley lodges to celebrate St. John's day by all 
gathering at one of these lodges. These meetings were always well attended, and for the 
good of the Order. Brother Van Fleet, who is so well known among Colorado Masons and 
who has done so much for Masonry, saw these lodges growing, not only in enthusiasm but 
in numbers, noticed that it was beginning to become somewhat burdensome for one lodge 
to take care of the immense crowd that assembled on St. John's day, thought that it would 
be nice to have a place to celebrate this day - a place that Masons could call their own. 


Accordingly, at the meeting of these lodges, June 24, 1913, it was decided to appoint a 
committee to plan otherwise for these annual celebrations. This committee, after careful 
consideration and much effort, decided to buy a hundred and sixty acres. This was done, 
and the Association incoiporated under the laws of Colorado as a “Non-profit 
Incorporation.” 


The first Association meeting was held at this park June 24, 1914. There were present at 
that celebration five hundred Masons, their families and friends. Conservative estimates 
place the number attending the last gathering, June 24, 1920, at fifteen hundred, three 
times that of the first annual celebration in this park. 


Masonic Park contains one hundred and sixty acres of land on both sides of the Rio 
Grande river, is located about fifty miles from Alamosa, Colo., and three miles above 
South Fork. It has been plotted, with that broad spirit of fraternity and brotherly feeling 
with which the Western Mason is endowed, to sell to Masons at only $25.00 per lot. The 
Association has opened this park to all Master Masons and their families, and invites them 
to buy lots and erect summer cottages, and make this their summer home. 



The location of Masonic Park is one of the most beautiful and picturesque spots of the 
Rocky Mountains. The Denver & Rio Grande Railroad and the Rio Grande River (Cut No. 
3) run through the park from northwest to southeast. The elevation is about 8,200 feet. 

Fine fishing and hunting in season an ideal place to spend a summer vacation and 
rejuvenate for the coming year's work. 


Trains on the Denver & Rio Grande Railroad (Cut No. 4) pass through Masonic Park 
twice each day. It is worth while making a trip over the D. & R.G. from Alamosa to 
Creede. The scenery along this route is the best, and the mines and other historic points of 
more than ordinary interest. Creede, it will be recalled, is the town in which the slayer of 
Jesse James, the outlaw, was shot. 


The elevation of the Rio Grande river at Masonic Park is 8,200 feet above sea level. The 
Association has already built a bridge across the river (Cut No. 5), and erected a large 
pavilion. Several cottages have been erected, and many more are contemplated in the near 
future. 


A large spring (Cut No. 6) has been opened on the top of the mountain, and fine mountain 
water piped to every cottage in the park. To the left of the big pavilion there is a winding 
path leading up to this spring which supplies Masonic Park with pure mountain water, it 
being piped from this spring. To the unaccustomed and inexperienced in mountain hiking, 
this will be a good beginning. It is 1500 feet up this trail, and in places you may have to 
“pull yourself up” by catching the twigs occasionally. When you get to the spring, you will 
enjoy a drink of this clear, cold water. You can then continue as much further, if you 
desire. On the top of this peak, you have a bird’s-ye view of the surrounding mountams 
and river that becomes more interesting the longer you stand and gaze. You gain three 
things by taking this short hike: The benefit of the climb, a drink of good water, and a look 
at what nature has done. After you descend, you may enjoy a camp breakfast of trout, or 
an additional nap, or both. 



Inquiries are being received from Masons of Iowa, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, 
Missouri, Texas, and other central States, and no doubt ere long Masonic Park will be the 
summer home for Masons and their families from these and many other states. 


The principal forms of recreation to be enjoyed in and around Masonic Park are hunting, 
fishing, hiking, packing, camping, automobiling and picnicking. In hunting and fishing, 
the only restrictions are the reasonable requirements of the Colorado game laws. 


Outdoor recreation is a necessity of our modem civilized life, and as civilization becomes 
more intensive this necessity increases and the demand grows keener. The infant as well as 
grandmother; in fact, every member of the family must have a vacation of some kind. 
Summer is growing time for children as well as for gardens. The mountains, glaciers, 
lakes, streams, and spring water to drink, contribute largely and effectively to human 
health and enjoyment - help to make strong, sturdy boys and girls out of delicate babies. 
The human value of a summer spent at Masonic Park would indeed be hard to estimate. 


Chapelle, Willow, Elk, Myers, Beaver and Trout Creeks are within from one to nine miles 
of Masonic Park, and easily accessible by team or automobile. Fishing is good in all of 
them, and present fine scenery to the tourist and camper. The roads throughout this section 
of Colorado are first-class, and are being made better each year. State highway No. 15 runs 
through the property. The state highway from Denver to the San Juan country is but three 
miles east of the park. The South Fork of the Rio Grande, another stream famous for its 
hunting and fishing, is but a short drive from the park; in fact, Masonic Park is ideally 
located in every respect for a summer home. There is a large brick furnace on which 
campers may prepare their meals. There is plenty of wood, and water has been piped into 
this Public Cook House. 


The annual Association meeting, June 24, is the day when all Masons of the San Fuis 
Valley are as one great family. Every one brings his lunch, and the Association furnishes 
ice cream, lemonade and hot coffee, and St. John's day spent at Masonic Park will never 
be forgotten. 



Following is the description of the outing, June 24, 1920, as published in The Alamosa 
Courier. This conveys an idea of this outing: 


“The San Luis Valley Masonic association, which is composed of Del Norte, Monte Vista, 
Saguache, Center, Hooper and Alamosa lodges, met in the twenty-sixth annual 
communication on St. John's day, June 24, at Masonic Park, Colorado. 


“The day was spent in general intercourse and in becoming better acquainted. After a most 
sumptuous basket lunch, which each individual furnished, supplemented by ice cream and 
coffee, furnished by the association, addresses were made by Frank L. Bishop, Grand 
Master of Masons of Colorado; W.W. Cooper, Grand Lecturer of Colorado, and ex- 
Govemor Alva Adams, Inspector General of Colorado for the Southern Jurisdiction 
Scottish Rite Masons. 


“Mr. Adams' address was an inspiration to all who were fortunate in getting into the 
pavilion to hear it. He is conceded to be one of the best talkers in the state. His address 
treated of the history of the San Luis Valley, and no one is better qualified to discuss its 
history than is Mr. Adams. 


“The meeting was presided over by our fellow townsman, Marshall H. Van Fleet, Senior 
Grand Warden of the Grand Lodge of Colorado. Mr. Van Fleet also acted as general 
manager of the day's festivities. 


“After the program was concluded, the young folks were permitted, with the assistance of 
the Alamosa orchestra, to trip the fantastic, in which they joyously indulged until about 
nine o'clock in the evening, stopping just long enough to try and finish the remnants of the 
basket picnic dinner. 


“It was an ideal day and the number present was estimated at from sixteen to eighteen 
hundred. One party calmed to nave counted bud automobiles. A conservative estimate is 



five persons to the car. Quite a number came on the train. It was one of the most wonderful 
gatherings ever held in the San Luis Valley, and the largest attendance in the history of the 
association during the last twenty-six years, practically all being Masons, their families 
and relatives. 


“The Masonic Park is situated on the Rio Grande river, fifty miles west of Alamosa, and is 
one of the most beautiful spots in the Rocky Mountain region. It is owned by the Masons 
of the San Luis Valley, and a Mason from any place is privileged to buy a lot, build him a 
summer home and become a member of the association. 


“To date the association has spent nearly $20,000 in the erection of two large pavilions 
and piping water from a spring upon the mountain, which can be piped into every cabin on 
the grounds; the building of a bridge across the river and other extensive improvements to 
make it a first-class summer resort for Masons and their families. 


“Fishing in the Rio Grande is always attractive to the angler, and the park is so situated 
that it is only a short automobile drive to the South Fork of the Rio Grande river, Goose 
Creek and the head waters of the Rio Grande river. 


“The Wheeler national park is easily accessible, and few people, even of the San Luis 
Valley, realize the beauties, or know that we have a national park in our widst, one of the 
most wonderful spots in the world - a large tract of land, a sort of wildemes - where the 
dirt has been washed away, leaving nothing but rocks, standing like giant trees pointing 
heavenward. 


“A number of prominent Masons from distant points were in attendance during the day, 
some from Texas, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, Ohio, in fact this Masonic Park is rapidly 
becoming known all over the country. 



“Masonic Park is as yet in its infancy, although it has made big strides in the short life of 
its existence, but in a few years it is going to be one of the most famous and widely known 
resorts of the state of Colorado. It is easy of access from almost any part of the valley. 


“There are no hotel accommodations in the park for tourists, but it is the intention of the 
association that all Masons going there shall be on an equality, and provide for their own 
comfort and convenience. No doubt, some day, some Mason will come along buy a lot, 
and build a hotel for the accommodation of touring Masons. 


“The Order of Eastern Star, which is the ladies' auxiliary of Masonry, has built a large 
pavilion. 


“Every year sees more and more cottages built, and in a few years Masonic Park will be 
the equal of any of the celebrated summer resorts in Colorado. 


“About a dozen good sized trout were caught during the day and presented to the speakers 
of the afternoon as a souvenir of this twenty-sixth annual celebration.” 


This Masonic Park is a new undertaking, practically in its infancy. The outlook is very 
encouraging, however, and the interest already manifested in this rather unique project, 
not only by the Masons in the valley but by Masons from distant points (one brother 
having written from the Philippines for a lot), insures its future. 


The San Luis Valley has a Masonic population well able to make this summer park home 
a brilliant success, but this is not wholly the intention of its founder and the Masons of 
the valley. They wish brethren from every part of the United States - from the we for that 
matter, to share with them in the pleasures and advantages offered by this park - this 
strictly Masonic recreation grounds, where Masons and their families may spend their 
vacations among the beauties of the Rocky Mountains. 



The lots are about fifty by one hundred feet, and may be purchased on the payment plan, 
if desired. The writer was at this park July 27, and personally talked with a contractor 
who was building a cottage with a sleeping porch. Being thirsty, we drank of the 
mountain water from a hydrant within six feet of this cottage. The contractor remarked 
about the quickness with which this cottage was supplied with excellent drinking water. 
About two weeks were required to build the cottage. Other cottages are in process 
construction. 


FREEMASONRY AMONG THE AMERICAN INDIANS 


BY BRO. ARTHUR C. PARKER, SECRETARY, NEW YORK STATE INDIAN 
COMMISSION 


One of the most frequent questions directed to the ethnologist who concerns himself with 
a study of the American aborigines is, "Are Indians Masons?" There have been various 
answers to this question, the reply depending on the informant's knowledge of Masonry. 
There are positive assertions both ways. There are also many rumours of lodges, signs 
and miraculous escapes due to the giving of some Masonic sign or exclamation denoting 
distress. The student is apt to be quite at loss to know what the real truth is and how 
much fiction has been woven about these assertions. 


The investigator might ask some Indian whether or not he ever heard of an Indian lodge 
of Freemasons and receive an affirmative answer; again an Indian of the same tribe 
might as positively declare that no such institution existed among his people. Now what 
is the truth? 


Today there are numerous Indians who are Free and Accepted Masons. One can scarcely 
travel in Oklahoma, Nebraska, Kansas or the Dakotas without meeting Indians who 
belong to the ancient fraternity. Many of the most influential Indians of the Dakotas and 
especially of Oklahoma have full knowledge of the mysteries of Masonry and have 



sought further light in the concordant orders, yet so far as is known to the writer no 
exclusively Indian lodge exists. 


But what of the older Indians who inherit the traditions of their forefathers, do they not 
have lodges of their own not connected with the rite as the white man knows it? Surely 
there is plenty of testimony as to this. 


In "The Freemasons Library" by Samuel Cole, published in Baltimore in 1826 is this 
quotation from the Masonic Mirror, (date not given): 


"Travellers describe certain private societies among the Indians which apparently 
resemble our lodges of Free Masons. Their rules and government of admission of 
members are said to be nearly the same. No one can be received as a member of the 
fraternity except by ballot, and the concurrence of the whole is necessary to a choice. 
They have different degrees in the order. The ceremonies of initiation, and the mode of 
passing from one degree to the other, would create astonishment in the mind of an 
enlightened spectator. 


"A similar institution, it is said, prevails among our Iroquois. These have never been 
suspected of Welsh extraction. Still they may have derived the signs from those who 
were. We receive the information from Gov. Clinton, to whom it was communicated by 
a respectable Indian preacher, who received the signs of the mystery from a Menonie 
(Menominee) chief. The institution, therefore, must be prevalent among the Menonies as 
well as other Indians. In this secret institution among the Indians, the members are very 
select. Among the Iroquois the society consists of five Oneidas, two St. Regis and six 
Senecas. They are said to have secret signs, and pretend that the institution has existed 
from eternity. The period of their meetings is unknown; but they assemble once in three 
years, as deputies, under pretense of other business." 


In considering the question of freemasonry two views may be taken, one that there is a 
universal freemasonry in which through the medium of philosophical and symbolic 
teachings a system of morality is inculcated by a brotherhood; and the second that Free 



and Accepted Masonry does not exist unless able to show a charter or dispensation from 
some Grand Body of competent Masonic jurisdiction. According to the second view any 
similar is not "Free and Accepted Masonry" but an extra-limital institution without any 
ties of affiliation. This view makes the possession of a charter and adherence to a certain 
basic constitution of primary importance. The first view, however, recognizes that there 
is an universal freemasonry and asserts that adherence to certain principles and a certain 
type of ceremonies leading to the expression of a certain set of moral ideas of primary 
importance. Both of these views are correct within their fields. 


If we make the term "freemasonry" or "universal freemasonry" generic, then any form of 
freemasonry, that embraces the characteristics of freemasonry, may be said to be a part 
of a great whole. If, on the other hand, we define freemasonry as a certain system and 
organization controlled by certain Grand Lodges of competent jurisdiction, each Grand 
Lodge recognizing the other and having fraternal intercourse with it, then we take the 
specific view and refer to "Free and Accepted Masons." 


For the sake of our subject let us admit that there is an extra-limital or universal 
freemasonry which men outside the order itself may discover and understand. This is not 
unreasonable to the philosophy of the organized craft. Let competent Masons remember 
where they first became Masons, though their eyes had not beheld or their minds 
conceived the beauties of a single Masonic rite. Yet, having once seen and understood, 
their previous beliefs were shaped by the ritual and the power of true faith confirmed and 
put to labour. 


With this thought before us let us examine the beliefs and principles of the American 
Indians and see whether or not any were capable of erecting out of these things the 
superstructure that might be fitly termed "a temple of Masonry." 


1 . The red man of America believed in a Supreme Deity. Many authorities have denied 
this, some of them, perhaps, through prejudice and some of them through a 
misunderstanding of the words translated gods, spirits, powers. Perhaps some who have 
denied that the Indians had the one God concept have done so because they desired to 
prove that the white man and his religion brought this idea to the "benighted heathen." 
But however this may be there were some cults among the many tribes that saw back of 



the god of the winds, the god of the thunder, the god of the rivers and the god of the 
harvest, a supreme god who was the chief of all and who ruled the powers of the air as 
his subordinates. Imperfectly understood, perhaps, was this Supreme Architect, but 
nevertheless he was known if but feebly. And how well understood and known today is 
the concept of Deity? We have knowledge of the ineffable name, and, likewise, the red 
man of the desert, the plains and the forest gave a name to this Omnipotence. Whether to 
the Algonquin it was Gitche Manitou, to the Pawnee Tirawa, to the Sioux Wakanda, or 
to the Iroquois Haweniu, the same idea prevailed, - that of the one Great Spirit who was 
the Creator. The Supreme Architect of the Universe to the American Indian was the 
Maker-of-All. 


2. The practice of virtue was demanded of the red man. He must be just in his dealings 
with his fellows. He must be truthful, considerate, hospitable and loyal. He was likewise 
taught to be stoical, slow to anger, slow to announce personal discomfort and to exercise 
due toleration for the views of his fellows. At all times he must acknowledge his 
dependence upon his Creator and never undertake any great or important underrating 
without first invoking the aid of Deity. He actually did this and at all times rendered 
thanks for the blessings he enjoyed. To be thankful and never do anything that would 
lead the Maker to think his creature ungrateful was one of the great essentials of the 
religions of the Indian. 


3. "There is a future life," announced the red man. It was one of his most inbred beliefs. 
His elaborate funeral ceremonies were built up upon this faith. This was a visible world 
but there was an invisible world inhabited by innumerable spirits of departed creatures, - 
men, animals, plants. Whether it was called the "Happy Hunting Ground," the "World 
Beyond the Sky," "the Abode of the Creator," - to the Indian it was the home-world of 
spirits; it was heaven. A thousand ceremonies and a myriad of prayers were devised 
because of this deeply rooted belief. It may have been superstitious to have called to 
Haweniu in the World- Abo ve-the- Sky and to have attempted to talk to departed spirits of 
animals and friends, but nevertheless, in it all a belief was expressed. 


4. One of the most precious beliefs of the Indian was that of the universal and eternal 
kinship of all created things. This belief affected and influenced the Indian in every act 
of his life. Man was not only the brother of man because a Supreme Father had created 
both, but every animal, plant and rock, as well as every force of nature was believed to 
sustain a certain spiritual relationship to man, and man had certain obligations to them. 



The deer and bear were brothers and "very near man." The trees and waterfalls had 
spirits. Thus, the red man thought it quite rational to speak to them as friends and 
brothers. Animals were not killed in a wanton way, but when it became necessary to kill 
for meat and pelt a propitiary sacrifice was given and the spirit of the animal invoked for 
pardon. "I have killed you," chanted the Indian, "that I might use your meat and fur. 
Should you need me I, too, am here. But the Creator has given me great cunning and I 
have used that power fairly. Hold no evil thought about me, your soul is the real of you 
and to it I will render pleasing sacrifice. Ascend in peace, my brother, and be happy. 
This incense is grateful to you, these beads will show you that I desire to render you a 
gift. I have spoken." 


To the Indian the creatures of earth were kinsmen, though different in form from man. 
This mattered not for the Creator made all to suit his puipose. The food and 
pharmaceutal plants of the forest were not taken without a thank offering and the 
planting of seeds in hole where the root had been. This feeling of fraternity worked out in 
many other ways as by the organization of numerous fraternities and societies, by the 
knitting of the clan and totemic systems and by the ties of a complex social organization. 
There were binding laws and customs that governed every social action and regulated 
conduct. So impressed was Roger Williams with the kindness and consideration which 
was shown him by the Indians among whom he laboured in New England that he wrote: 


"If Nature's sonnes both wild and tame, Humane and courteous be, How ill becomes it 
Sonnes of God To want humanity." 


Out of this brotherly feeling for fellow creatures there grew up many associations and 
fraternities devoted to one cause or another. Some were purely selfish, others were 
associations of warriors, others devoted to a propitiation to the spirits of the nature forces 
and still others were sworn brotherhoods devoted to charity, the preservation of ancient 
rites and to a system of reverent ceremonies whereby morals were inculcated. In recent 
years these societies have received much attention and study by ethnologists, particularly 
by those of the American Museum of Natural History of New York. (1) 


Out of these four characteristics of the more cultivated natives of the new world we may 
deduce their ability to construct an organization similar under the circumstances of forest 



and plains life to the freemasonry of the white man. It will easily be seen that the 
American Indians except through contact with white Masons could know nothing of the 
words used in Masonry nor could they know anything of the special initiatory rites. 

They might have signs, similar to Masonic signs but as for Asiatic words and Hebrew 
traditions they had nothing, notwithstanding the immature and superficial observations of 
those who have assumed to find them. Such assertions must today stand the inspection 
of the trained philologist and ethnologist, and they will not pass. Yet from what we have 
stated as to the beliefs of the Indians we may yet say whether or not they had the mental 
or moral capacities to understand Masonic light. 


Let us go further. Samuel Cole in the quotation we have cited mentions the Menominees 
and the Iroquois and says, "Travellers describe certain private societies among the 
Indians which apparently resemble our lodges of Free Masons." Let us see what these 
were and find out whether indeed there is any similarity. 


The Menominees of Wisconsin do have certain fraternal or "medicine" societies, among 
them the Mide Wiwin. It has several degrees culminating in the resurrection of the 
candidate who represents a slain hero. Alanson Skinner of the Museum of the American 
Indian is now writing a description of this ceremony as a contribution to the by-lights of 
Masonry. In due time we shall have the results. But Cole mentions, also, certain 
ceremonies of the Iroquois. About this group of native American natives, I feel free to 
speak, it being my special province to record their history and traditions for the State of 
New York. The Iroquois had a "grand medicine lodge" and still have several chapters 
among the Senecas and Onondagas. Its real name is Neh Ho-noh-chee-noh-ga Nee-ga- 
hee-ga-aa, which may be interpreted. "The Ancient Guards of the Mystic Potence." This 
society is the most influential among the non-christianized Iroquois of New York state 
today and numbers on its rolls many nominal Christians. It meets four times each year 
and holds one business session. 


Popularly this organization is called "The Little Water Society" because the "potence" 
which it guards is used ceremonially in connection with a cup of water, though other 
reasons are also ascribed. This potence is represented to be the tips of the hearts and the 
brain bases of the primitive founders of the society who gave the "sparks of their lives" 
that their hero and leader might be resurrected. These founders were the great game 
animals and birds and the major food plants, which had been befriended in times of dire 
distress by the Hero Chief. Slain and scalped by the foe they sacrificed themselves that 



he might live by the administration of the life essence which they gave him from an 
acorn cup. Thus, in the ceremonies today, the members impersonate these animal 
founders and at intervals in the tripartite ceremony, imitate their calls. The ritual is 
chanted in unison in three parts in total darkness. Between each section there is an 
interval of refreshment when the members drink strawberry juice, then eat honey, then 
partake of the fragrant native tobacco. The ritual is a long one and relates how in the end 
the slain Hero Chief is brought to his feet and to life by the firm grip of the bear's paw, 
his left paw concealing the grip of his right. 


The writer personally knows white persons who have witnessed these ceremonies. He 
has vouched for at least three who have been shown the mysteries. (2) Today there are 
flourishing lodges of this order of Ancient Guards of the Mystic Potence in the State of 
New York and in the province of Ontario, where the Iroquois still hold forth. 


It may be interesting to state further that the form of the lodge is an oblong and has two 
altars, one east and one west. Its ritual is sung or chanted by all the members, thereby 
rendering "lost words" or forgotten sections next to impossible. The society bears all the 
ear-marks of great antiquity and its members cling faithfully to it, for it is the tradition 
that when the Guards cease their vigilance that the red man will pass into extinction. 


The ceremonial lesson taught is that a man should willingly lay down his life if need be 
to save the life of him who has sacrificed to save his, and the ritual shows that through 
enduring love for one's fellow man and the potency of sacrifice the Great Spirit will 
restore life and health though both have gone. 


There is a strange similarity between this ceremony and the rites of Osiris, whereby he is 
raised by the lion. Perhaps the same mystery has appealed to the minds of many races 
widely separated by time and space. Perhaps this shows that certain elements in 
Freemasonry are universal in their appeal and that all men have reached out for them, 
some wisely and well and some imperfectly. Yet the fact that many have sought proves 
that there may be an extra-limital masonry, as if some uninstructed groups of mankind 
saw through a glass darkly, - and craved more light. 



The researches of the American Bureau of Ethnology, of the American Museum of 
Natural History and of the State Museum of New York, as well as other public and 
private institutions clearly prove the existence of numerous cults and fraternities among 
the American Indians. That some should have certain attributes similar to Masonry is 
not strange. The human mind and heart whether in barbarism or in enlightenment 
hungers for knowledge, longs for genuine friendship, and knows that without morality no 
society can endure 


(1) Vide Anthropological Papers, American Museum, N.Y. City. 


(2) Vide Publications of Buffalo Consistory, A.A.S.R., G.K. Staples, Commander, 
"American Indian Freemasonry." 


WOMAN AND FREEMASONRY 


BY BRO. DUDLEY WRIGHT, ENGLAND 


Wise men tell us that there never has been a woman Freemason. Perhaps that is true. 
This question has been called to the attention of the able scholar and devoted Mason who 
contributes this series of articles. Can Freemasonry enlarge its borders to include women 
or must they forever remain outside the pale? If they are to be made Masons in literal 
truth in what way can we reorganize the ritual so as to eliminate certain features which 
might prove embarassing to them? If they cannot be admitted into full membership in 
what way can the spirit and teachings of this ancient Fraternity be made available to 
them? Since Freemasonry began to be this has been a moot question; it is still. It will be 
for years to come. It is a theme of perrennial interest. For this reason we are very glad 
indeed to give to our readers the reasoned and mature judgments of a scholar who has 
every right to speak on this interesting question. 


EGYPTIAN MASONRY AND COUNT CAGLIOSTRO 



IMMEDIATELY after the downfall of Napoleon, societies were formed in various 
European countries, chiefly by exiles for the promotion of Italian independence. Even 
Egypt became a centre of this propaganda and, under the auspices of Mehemet Ali, who 
aspired to render himself independent of the Sublime Porte, an Egyptian rite was 
established under the name of the "Secret Egyptian Society." In the lodges of Alexandria 
and Cairo alone, the Greek and Arab women numbered more than three hundred. 


Closely bound up with this Egyptian Masonry was the celebrated unprincipled 
adventurer, Joseph Balsamo, better known as the Count Cagliostro, who imposed upon 
our Masonic forefathers as he did upon the rest of the world. In 1776, he was initiated 
into Freemasonry in the Esperance Lodge, No. 289, which was attached to what was 
known as the Rite of Strict Observance. The lodge met at the King's Head Tavern in 
Gerrard Street, Soho, W., and was composed mainly of French and Italian brethren. His 
entry into the Craft was made through the mediumship of Comte de Sainte Germain. 


In Courland Count and Madame Cagliostro established Masonic lodges under what they 
claimed to be sublime rites of Egyptian Masonry, which he claimed it was his mission to 
restore; and in Paris he prosecuted with great vigour his plans to resuscitate Freemasonry 
according to the Egyptian rite. A lodge was founded at Lyons by Cagliostro, to which 
was given the name of "Triumphant Wisdom," and this was regarded as the Mother 
Lodge of the rite. Its patent was as follows: 


Honour, Wisdom Union, Beneficence, Comfort. We, Grand Copt in all Eastern and 
Western parts of Europe, Founder and Grand Master of Egyptian Masonry, make known 
to All who may read this that during our stay at Lyons many members of the Lodge of 
the Orient and Ordinary Rite, which has adopted the distinguishing title of "Wisdom" 
have expressed their ardent wish to place themselves under our rule, to be enlightened in 
true Masonry. 


We are pleased to accede to their wish, etc., etc. 



Madame Cagliostro was Grand Mistress of the Lodge of Isis, which, in 1784, counted 
among its Adepts some of the most prominent of French titled women. 


On 7th August, 1785, there was a great ceremony of initiation in a mansion in Rue Verte, 
Faubourg Saint-Honore, Paris, when thirty-six females were admitted into the Order. 
Each initiate had to contribute the sum of one hundred lois, to undertake to abstain from 
all intimacy with mankind and to submit to everything which might be imposed on 
them. On entering the first apartment of the mansion, the ladies were ordered to disrobe 
and to put on a white garment with a coloured girdle. The candidates were then 
separated into six groups of six candidates, each group wearing different coloured 
girdles. They were then conducted into a temple lighted from the roof and seated upon 
thirty-six arm-chairs upholstered in black satin. Madame Cagliostro, clothed in white, 
was seated on a throne, and, when the light was lowered, she commanded the candidates 
to uncover the left leg to above the knee, to raise the right arm and to rest it upon an 
adjacent pillar. The Grand Mistress then delivered an oration, which advocated the 
emancipation of woman-kind from the shameful bonds imposed upon them by men. At 
the conclusion of the oration, the candidates were conducted to separate apartments, each 
of which opened on to the garden. There they were visited by male admirers, but, having 
regard to the oath taken, they refused to enter into any conversation with them and 
spurned all overtures, and, after a time, the thirty-six were conducted once more into the 
temple. Within a short time, the vaulted roof opened suddenly, and Cagliostro, seated on 
a golden sphere, as naked as he was born, holding a serpent in his hand, and with a 
flaming star an his head, descended into their midst. The Grand Mistress announced that 
this was the Genius of Truth, the divine Cagliostro, who had come to initiate them into 
the secrets of Freemasonry. Cagliostro, or the Grand Copt, as he described himself, then 
ordered them to dispense with all their clothing. If they were to receive the truth, they 
must be as naked as Truth. The example of dispensing with clothing was set by the 
Grand Mistress and followed by the thirty-six candidates. Cagliostro then delivered his 
address, at the conclusion of which he was hauled up on his golden sphere through the 
opening in the roof. The ladies clothed themselves and the evening terminated in an 
elaborate banquet, when the initiates were joined by their male acquaintances, 
notwithstanding the obligations they had taken. 


Cagliostro asserted that this particular brand of Masonry was instituted by Enoch and its 
teachings promulgated by Elijah. As Grand Copt he claimed to possess the power of 
communicating with angels and to be enaned to accomplish wonders through the 
miraculous power with which he had been divinely endowed. All religions were 



tolerated under his system: a belief in God was the sole qualification for membership. 
The Obligation taken by candidates was as follows: 


I swear before the Eternal God, the Grand Mistress, and all who hear me, never to write 
or cause to be written anything that shall pass under my eyes, condemning myself in the 
event of imprudence and to be punished according to the laws of the grand founders and 
of all my superiors. I likewise promise the exact observance of the other six 
commandments imposed upon me: that is to say, love of God, respect for the sovereign, 
veneration for religion and the laws, love of my fellow-creatures, an attachment without 
bounds to our Order, and an unquestioning submission to the rules and code of our ritual 
as ma be communicated to me by the Grand Mistress. 


On the initiation of a candidate the Grand Mistress breathed on her face from the 
forehead to the chin, saying: 


I thus breathe upon you to cause the Truth possessed by us to germinate and penetrate 
within your heart; I breathe upon you to fortify your spiritual part; I breathe upon you to 
confirm you in the faith of your brethren and sisters, in accordance with your 
undertaking. We greet you as a lawful daughter of Egyptian Masonry of the Lodge; We 
desire that you be recognized as such by all the Brethren and Sisters of the Egyptian 
ritual, and that you enjoy the same prerogatives as they. Lastly, we impart to you the 
supreme pleasure of being henceforth and forever a Freemason. 


The ceremony of the Third degree was rendered with great pomp and ceremony. On that 
occasion a young, innocent girl, to whom was given the name of columba (dove), was 
introduced, and the Grand Master claimed to impart to her the power he possessed of 
communing with spiritual beings. These spirits were said to be seven in number, 
governing the seven planets and surrounding the throne of the Eternal, their names being 
Azael, Michael, Raphael, Gabriel, Ariel, Zobiachel, and Anachiel. The girl, who was 
clothed in a long, white robe, which was adorned with blue ribbons, and wearing a scarf, 
was shut up in a tabernacle which was placed on the altar of the temple. From a window 
in this tabernacle she gave the replies to the questions asked her, which related generally 
to the fitness of the candidate for advancement to the degree. 



The emblems used in Egyptian Masonry were the triangle, the septangle, the trowel, the 
compasses, the square, the gavel, the death's head, the cube, the rough ashlar, a wooden 
bridge, Jacob's ladder, the Phoenix, the globe, and Father Time. 


The following advertisement from Cagliostro appeared in the Morning Herald in 
November, 1786, explanatory words, which did not appear in the advertisement, being 
placed in brackets: 


TO ALL TRUE MASONS 


In the Name of 9, 5, 8, 14, 20, 1, 8 [Jehovah]; 9, 5, 18, 20, 18. [Jesus]. 


The Time is at hand when the Building of the New Temple or New Jerusalem, 3, 8, 20, 
17, 8 [Church] must begin; this is to invite all True Masons in London to join in the 
Name of 9, 5, 18, 20, 18, [Jesus] the only one in whom there is a Divine 19, 17, 9, 13,9, 
19, 23 [Trinity] to meet tomorrow evening, the 3d instant, 1786 (or 5790), at Nine 
o'clock at Riley's, Great Queen Street; to lay a plan for the laying the first stone of the 
foundation of the true 3, 8, 20, 17, 8; [Church] in this visible world, being the, material 
representative Temple of the Spiritual 9, 5, 17, 20, 18, 11, 5, 12. [Jerusalem], 


A Mason, and member of the new 3, 8, 20, 17, 8. [Church], 


It is not without interest to note that, in 1789, Cagliostro was arrested by the police and 
taken to the castle of St. Angelo, where he died. His Egyptian Masonry, so called, 
perished with him. 


THE ORDER OF THE EASTERN STAR 



The Order of the Eastern Star is believed to be the fifth largest fraternal organization and 
the largest female Order in the world. It had in 1917 nearly 900,000 members and its 
membership roll is increasing at the rate of 50,000 a year. It does not claim to be a 
Masonic Order, although its membership is restricted, in the case of men, to those who 
are already members of the Masonic Brotherhood, and, in the case of women, to those 
whose nearest male relatives or connections are Freemasons of good standing. It is the 
custom of the Chapters of the Eastern Star to hold their meetings in the lodge rooms or 
temples of Masonic lodges, when such permission can be obtained, but the Order does 
not come under the category of "Adoptive Masonry." The term "Adoptive" implies the 
power of government and control, and this is not exercised by any Masonic body in 
regard to the Order of the Eastern Star. 


The Order is believed to have taken its rise in the United States of America in 1778, but 
it did not attain any degree of eminence until 1850, when it was revived by Rob. Morris, 
a prominent American Freemason. The various units were known as "Constellations," 
and, in 1855, a "Supreme Constellation" was established, though it does not appear to 
have had a long life. The Order itself, however, continued to flourish and, in 1874 a 
serious attempt was made to organize a Supreme Grand Chapter, which, two years later, 
was crowned with success. District or Provincial Grand Chapters have since been 
established in all quarters of the globe and the Order is making great headway in 
Scotland. England stands practically alone in her aloofness from the Order. The utmost 
care is evinced in the admission of candidates. The fee for initiation and the annual 
subscription are moderate, averaging twelve shillings and five shillings respectively, and 
a certain proportion of each is devoted to beneficence. The Order is doing a noble and 
unselfish work and it was the first to establish a Masonic Home in Kansas, charging 
itself also with the furnishing of the Home on its erection. In the various States of 
America members are, at their own expense, building cottages, furnishing and supplying 
them with every need, and, in some instances, constmcting hospitals and maintaining 
them. 


When the Eastern Star Chapter is held in the Masonic lodge room or temple it is the 
custom to make no charge for rent, light or heating. A candidate for initiaton must be 
recommended by two members from personal knowledge. A committee of three is then 
appointed to report upon the application at the next meeting, when a ballot is taken for 
the admission of the applicant, and this ballot must be unanimous. 



The main object of the Order of the Eastern Star is to give practical effect to the 
beneficent purpose of Freemasonry, particularly in provision for the wives, daughters, 
widows, mothers, and sisters of members of the Craft, and, at the same time, inculcate 
various principles. These principles are five in number, represented by the five Degrees 
of the Order and said to be read by the enlightened in the cabbalistic motto of the Order - 
F.A.T.A.L. They are as follows: 


1. Fidelity to vocations of right and duty. This is the teaching of the Degree of 
Jephthah's daughter, as set forth in XI Judges, verses 30-40. 


2. Obedience to the demands of honour and justice in all conditions of life. This is the 
teaching of the Degree of Ruth and is set forth in I Ruth, verses 16 and 17. 


3. Fidelity to kindred and friends. This is illustrated in the Degree of Esther and set forth 
in IV Esther, verse 2, and VII Esther, verses 2-5. 


4. Trustful faith in the hour of trial. This is the teaching of the Degree of Martha and set 
forth in the character of Martha. 


5. Heroic endurance of the wrongs of persecution when demanded in the defence of 
truth. This is illustrated in the character of Electa, or "the elect lady" as shown in the 
narrative recorded in the second epistle of St. John. 


The badge of the Order is a five-pointed star, the first point being blue with a sword and 
veil to represent Adah, or Jephthah's daughter. The second is yellow with a sheaf of 
barley to represent Ruth. The third is white and bears a crown and sceptre to represent 
Esther. The fourth is coloured green and has a broken column to represent Martha. The 
fifth is red, with a golden cup to represent Electa. 



In the Manual of the Order of the Eastern Star the following historical essay on the 
foundation and aims of certain secret institutions appears: 


Secret Societies imitating Freemasonry for the admission of females as members were 
first organized in France during the early part of the eighteenth century, and still exist 
there and in other parts of Europe, as a distinctive rite. By the term "Adoptive Masonry" 
is implied that system of forms, ceremonies, and explanatory lectures which is 
communicated to certain classes of ladies, who from their relationship by blood or 
marriage to Master Masons in good standing, are entitled to the respect and attention of 
the entire Fraternity. These ladies are said to be adopted into the Masonic communion 
because the system of forms, ceremonies, and lectures above referred to enables them to 
express their wishes, and gives satisfactory evidence of their claims in a manner that no 
stranger to the Masonic family can do. To the organization thus established for the 
initiation of females the French have given the name of "Adoptive Masonry," 
"Maconnerie d' Adoption," and the lodges are called "Foges d' Adoption," or "Adoptive 
Fodges," because every lodge of females was obliged to be adopted by, and under the 
guardianship of, some regular Masonic lodge. One of the first of these Societies was the 
"Order of Perfect Happiness," for so we may be permitted to translate the name 
"Felicitaires", which they adopted. This Society assumed a nautical character in its 
emblems and its vocabulary. It was divided into the four degrees of "Cabin Boy," 
"Master," "Commodore," and "Vice-Admiral." What little information we have been 
enabled to obtain from a very brief notice of its ritual leads us to believe that it was not 
of a character to merit countenance. It did not long retain its existence, for two years 
after its formation it gave place to the "Knights and Heroines of the Anchor," which was, 
however, but a refinement of the original Society, and preserved its formula of initiation 
and nearly all its ceremonies. In 1747, one Beauchaine, the Master of one of the Parisian 
lodges, instituted a new Society, which he called "F'Ordre des Fendeurs," or "The Order 
of Wood Cutters." This institution borrowed its principal ceremonies from the Society of 
the Carbonari, or Coal-burners, which had been previously established in Italy. The 
place of meeting of the Woodcutters was called the Wood Yard, and was supposed to 
represent a forest; the presiding officer was called "Father Master" and the male and 
female members were called "Cousins." The Society became at once exceedingly 
popular, and the most distinguished ladies and gentlemen of France united themselves to 
it. It was consequently the cause of the institution of many similar societies, such as the 
Order of the Hatchet, of Fidelity, etc. In consequence of the increasing popularity of the 
numerous secret associations which, in their external characters and mysterious rites, 
attempted an imitation of Freemasonry - differing, however, from that Institution, of 



which they were, perhaps, the rivals for public favour, by the admission of female 
members - the Grand Orient of France, in 1774, established a new rite, called the "Rite of 
Adoption," which was placed under the control of the Grand Orient. Rules and 
regulations were thenceforth provided for the government of these Lodges of Adoption, 
one of which was that no men should be permitted to attend them except regular 
Freemasons, and that each lodge should be placed under the charge and held under the 
sanction and warrant of some regularly constituted Masonic lodge, whose Master or, in 
his absence, his Deputy, should be the presiding officer, assisted by a female president or 
mistress. Under these regulations a Lodge of Adoption was opened in Paris in 1775, 
under the patronage of the Lodge of St. Anthony, and in which the Duchess of Bourbon 
presided, and was installed as Grand Mistress of the Adoptive Rite. Many systems of 
Adoptive Masonry have from time to time been introduced in the United States with 
varied success, none of which, however, seems to possess the elements of permanency, 
except the Order of the Eastern Star, which was established in this country during the 
year 1778. The success of this Order, therefore, corresponds in its beneficence and 
usefulness with the extent of Freemasonry. Its obligations are based upon the honour of 
the female sex, and framed upon the principles of equality and justice; that whatever 
benefits are due by the Masonic Fraternity TO the wives, widows, daughters, and sisters 
of Freemasons, corresponding benefits are due FROM them to the members of the 
Masonic Fraternity. The theory of the Order of the Eastern Star is founded upon the 
Holy Writings. Five prominent female characters, illustrating as many Masonic virtues, 
are selected, adopted, and placed under Masonic protection. The selections are: 


1. Jepthah's daughter, illustrating respect to the binding force of a vow. 


2. Ruth, illustrating devotion to religious principles. 


3. Esther, illustrating fidelity to kindred friends. 


4. Martha, illustrating undeviating faith in the hour of trial. 


5. Electa, illustrating patience and submission under wrongs. 



These are all Masonic virtues, and have nowhere in history more brilliant exemplars than 
in the five characters, illustrated in the lectures of the Order of the Eastern Star. 


The honourable and exalted puiposes had in view in its dissemination can have no 
opposition worthy the name. Its effects in winning to the advocacy of Masonry the 
virtuous, intelligent, and influential lady members of our families are truly encouraging, 
and stimulates its friends to persevere in a general promulgation of the system. 

According to the tenets of the Order of the Eastern Star, Adoptive Masonry stands a 
bright monument to female secrecy and fidelity, and proves how wrong all those are who 
fancy a woman is not to be trusted. There is not in the whole of the ceremonies of this 
rite a single point with which the most ascetic moralist could find fault. On the contrary, 
all is pure, all is beautiful; it is among the brightest jewels which spangle the records of 
Masonry. As the Adoptive privileges of the lady entirely depend upon the good standing 
and affiliation of the brother through whom she is introduced, this system will be a 
strong inducement, it is thought, to keep a brother, otherwise inclined to err, within the 
bounds of morality. A general diffusion of this rite will tend to supersede the other so- 
called female degrees as being, at the best, but trivial and henceforth superfluous and 
useless. 


CO-MASONRY 


In 1879 several Chapters owning allegiance to the Supreme Council of France of the 
Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite, at the instigation of the Grand Orient, seceded from 
that allegience and reconstituted themselves as La Grande Loge Symbolique de France. 
One of these Chapters, bearing the name of Les Libres Penseurs, meeting at Pecq, a 
village of Seine et Oise, in November 1881, proposed to initiate into Freemasonry, Mile. 
Maria Desraimes, a well-known writer on Humanitarian and women suffrage questions, 
which they did on 14th January, 1882, for which act the Lodge or Chapter was 
suspended. Mile. Desraimes was instrumental in bringing into the ranks of Freemasonry 
several other well-known women in France, with the result that an Androgynous 
Masonic body, known as La Grande Loge Symbolique Ecossaise was formed on 4th 
April, 1 893 although its jurisdiction at that time extended over only one lodge, that 
known as Le Droit Humain, which came into being on the same day, and which, in 1 900, 
adopted the thirty degrees of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite. One of the 



principal workers in the formation of this new schismatic Grand lodge was Dr. Georges 
Martin, at one time a member of the Lodge Les Libres Penseurs. The schismatic 
movement spread to Paris and Benares and afterwards to London, at which last-named 
place, in September, 1902, the Lodge "Human Duty," now No. 6 on the Co- Masonry 
Register, was consecrated. The title "Co-Masonry" in lieu of "Joint Masonry" was 
adopted in 1905. 


The Principles of Universal Co-Freemasonry are set forth in the official documents as 
follows: 


Art. 1 . Universal Co-Freemasonry in Great Britain asserts, in accordance with the ancient 
declarations of Freemasonry, the existence of a Creative Principle, under the title of "The 
Great Architect of the Universe." 


Art. 2. It maintains the open "Volumes of the Sacred Knowledge" in every lodge, when 
duly formed for Masonic purposes. 


Art. 3. It maintains the ancient landmarks of Freemasonry. 


Art. 4. It withholds recognition from all irregular and clandestine meetings, or lodges not 
holding proper charter. 


Art. 5. It imposes no restrictions on the free search for Truth, and to secure that freedom 
exacts tolerance from all its members. Art. 6. It is open to men and women, without 
distinction of race or religion, who are free, of good report, and irreproachable life. 


Art. 7. It pledges its members to obedience to the laws of the country, loyalty to the 
Sovereign, silence with regard to Masonic secrets, a high standard of honour, and 
ceaseless endeavour to promote the welfare of humanity. 



Art. 8. Every Freemason belonging to the Ancient and Accepted Rite is bound faithfully 
to observe the decision of the Supreme Council to which he owes allegiance. 


The movement is identified closely with the Theosophical Society, or that particular 
section of which Mrs. Annie Besant is President and, on the death of Dr. Georges Martin, 
the President Grand Master, Mrs. Besant was chosen to succeed him in that office. 


There is, however, another and a very influential branch of the Theosphical movement, 
which repudiates the Besant leadership, and with it the Co-Mason movement. This is 
presided over by Mrs. Katharine Tingley, who has set forth her views on Co-Masonry 
the following words: 


Let me first state what is my attitude towards Masonry. Many of the happiest 
recollections of my childhood are associated with my dead grandfather, who was one of 
the best known Masons in Massachusetts and Rhode Island, and received some of the 
highest Masonic honours in these States. It was from him that I received my earliest 
education. It was from his Masonic books that I learned to read and spell and draw, and 
from his noble and sweet character, I came to regard Masonry as associated with the best 
in life. In fact, I came to think that all the best men in the world must be Masons. 


Now, it does not necessarily follow that this last statement is true, for some of the noblest 
men I have met have not been Masons. Still, on the other hand, many of the best men I 
have known have belonged to the Masonic Order, and I have seen nothing but the best 
results flow from a deep interest in Masonry wherever I have known of it, and from my 
knowledge and acquaintance of Masons I regard Masonry and the principles which 
underlie it as a great force for good in the world. 


I cannot understand how any true woman would wish to intrude into an Order held to be 
exclusively for men. There are lines of work which I hold are exclusively in the 
province of men just as there are lines of work which are exclusively in the province of 



women. I hold that woman can only yield her full share of influence in the world from a 
knowledge gained by using and fulfilling her opportunities as a woman, and in her own 
sphere. I consider that she steps away from her true position and greatly lessens her 
influence by seeking to invade the sphere of man. 


Why should women be disturbed that men have an organization which is exclusively for 
men? As I understand Masonry, it seems to inculcate all the virtues - honour, rectitude, 
chastity, etc. - for this much has often been publicly stated by Masons; and, speaking 
generally, I have no hesitation in saying that, from my experience, the majority of them - 
to a degree at least - try to exemplify these virtues in their lives. There may be some 
who fall far short of the Masonic ideals - in our present disturbed civilization it can 
hardly be expected otherwise - but that cannot be laid at the door of Masonry, but of 
human frailty, and as a result of men's failing to grasp their higher opportunities in life. 


Many a woman has known of the uplifting and refining power, tending towards self- 
restraint and nobility and virtue, which Masonry has exercised in the life of brother, 
husband, or son; and without in any way encroaching on Masonry or seeking to pry into 
its secrets, every true woman, in the light of the knowledge that is publicly given out by 
Masons themselves of Masonic principles, can, if she will, help brother, husband, son or 
friend to be true to these principles and be a true Mason. 


What is needed today by both men and women is a greater respect, first for themselves, 
in their true natures as man and woman, and following that, a greater respect each for the 
other - of women for men and of men for women. Such respect implies no invasion of 
one another's sphere, but the very contrary, and in fact can only suffer terribly from such 
invasion. 


There is a common ground on which men and women can meet, which is preeminently 
in the home. It is also in the world of art, music, literature, education, and all the highest 
ideals of social, civic, and national life. 



I have had many letters from all classes asking questions as to my attitude in this matter, 
seeing that the name Theosophy has, most unfortunately, and without any warrant, 
become associated with "Co-Masonry." Such association is absolutely unwarranted, and 
I hold that no true Theosophist will give his adherence or support to "Co-Masonry." The 
fact that any person or body of persons should attempt to attach themselves to an 
organization from which, by the rules of that organization, they are excluded, would 
make me seriously question their motives, and one would probably find such people to 
be either fanatics or exeremely credulous or — (!) Whatever knowledge such people 
may think they have in the matter, it must indeed be very limited, or rather no knowledge 
at all, otherwise they would see the absurdity of trying to attach themselves to an 
organization in which, in the very nature of things, they would be out of place. If it were 
possible to conceive of the secrets of Masonry being given to a woman, from my 
understanding of the matter it could be only through some one unfaithful to his vows as a 
Mason, and no true and self-respecting woman would think of availing herself of such 
information; nor could it, by the nature of things, be held to be reliable, for he who is 
unfaithful in one thing will be unfaithful in others, and I prophesy that this attempt of 
certain women to seek admission where they do not belong can result only in confusion, 
disaster, and serious embarrassment for all such women. 


It need hardly be said that the clandestine movement of Co-Masonry is placed outside 
the pale by all who pledge their adherence to the Antient Charges of Freemasonry. 




SQUARE WITH THE WORLD 


BY BRO. L. B. MITCHELL, MICHIGAN 


Square with the world, square away to vision true, 
Never mind the creeds, 'tis the world you're holding to. 



Square with the world, 'twas for you laid in the plan 
That's forever right, for there was to be a man. 

And there was to be for him a way sublime 
In the plan of life with its rugged heights to climb, 

And 'twas left to him to prove that by the square 
The beautiful might e'en be made more fair. 

Square with the world, though no great deeds be done 
You may find just where there’s splendid greatness won; 
In the kindly ways, in the cheerful word and smile 
You may help so much to make life more worth while. 

O, there's so many, and such grand ways to Square 
Your life to this old world that's in your care! 

To be Square with youth and manhood in the race 
Will be forging on to earth's best, noblest place. 

Square with the world, as Square as earth to sun 
In the little things as in arduous duties done; 

'Tis the royal way, the relation to, that's grand, 

And itself the wage, paid in to heart and hand. 



Square with the world, to it your heart hold true, 
The adjustment rare will win the points for you 
For the old world holds its pathway in the skies 
For naught else save to help you win the prize. 




It is not what a man gets, but what a man is, that he should think of. He should think first 
of his character, and then of his condition: for if he have the former, he need have no fears 
about the latter. Character will draw condition after it. Circumstances obey principles. - 
H.W. Beecher. 


-o- 


Get into the habit of looking for the silver lining of the cloud, and, when you have found it, 
continue to look at it, rather than at the leaden gray in the middle. It will help you over 
many hard places. - Willitts. 




Nothing can work me damage, except myself. The ham that I sustain I carry about me, and 
never am a real sufferer but by my own fault. - St. Bernard. 


FOR THE MONTHLY LODGE MEETING 



CORRESPONDENCE CIRCLE BULLETIN NO. 42 


Edited by Bro. H. L. Haywood 


THE BULLETIN COURSE OF MASONIC STUDY FOR MONTHLY LODGE 
MEETINGS AND STUDY CLUBS 


FOUNDATION OF THE COURSE 


THE Course of Study has for its foundation two sources of Masonic information: THE 
BUILDER and Mackey's Encyclopedia. In another paragraph is explained how the 
references to former issues of THE BUILDER and to Mackey's Encyclopedia may be 
worked up as supplemental papers to exactly fit into each installment of the Course with 
the papers by Brother Haywood. 


MAIN OUTLINE: 


The Course is divided into five principal divisions which are in turn subdivided, as is 
shown below: 


Division I. Ceremonial Masonry. 


A. The Work of the Lodge. 

B. The Lodge and the Candidate. 



C. First Steps. 

D. Second Steps. 

E. Third Steps. 

Division II. Symbolical Masonry. 

A. Clothing. 

B. Working Tools. 

C. Furniture. 

D. Architecture. 

E. Geometry. 

F. Signs. 

G. Words. 

H. Grips. 

Division III. Philosophical Masonry. 

A. Foundations. 

B. Virtues. 

C. Ethics. 

D. Religious Aspect. 

E. The Quest. 

F. Mysticism. 


G. The Secret Doctrine. 



Division IV. Legislative Masonry. 


A. The Grand Lodge. 

1. Ancient Constitutions. 

2. Codes of Law. 

3. Grand Lodge Practices. 

4. Relationship to Constituent Lodges. 

5. Official Duties and Prerogatives. 

B. The Constituent Lodge. 

1. Organization. 

2. Qualifications of Candidates. 

3. Initiation, Passing and Raising. 

4. Visitation. 

5. Change of Membership. 

Division V. Historical Masonry. 

A. The Mysteries— Earliest Masonic Light. 

B. Studies of Rites— Masonry in the Making. 

C. Contributions to Lodge Characteristics. 



D. National Masonry. 

E. Parallel Peculiarities in Lodge Study. 

F. Feminine Masonry. 

G. Masonic Alphabets. 

H. Historical Manuscripts of the Craft. 

I. Biographical Masonry. 

J. Philological Masonry— Study of Significant Words. 


THE MONTHLY INSTALLMENTS 


Each month we are presenting a paper written by Brother Haywood, who is following the 
foregoing outline. We are now in "First Steps" of Ceremonial Masonry. There will be 
twelve monthly papers under this particular subdivision. On page two, preceding each 
installment, will be given a list of questions to be used by the chairman of the Committee 
during the study period which will bring out every point touched upon in the paper. 


Whenever possible we shall reprint in the Correspondence Circle Bulletin articles from 
other sources which have a direct bearing upon the particular subject covered by Brother 
Haywood in his monthly paper. These articles should be used as supplemental papers in 
addition to those prepared by the members from the monthly list of references. Much 
valuable material that would otherwise possibly never come to the attention of many of 
our members will thus be presented. 


The monthly installments of the Course appearing in the Correspondence Circle Bulletin 
should be used one month later than their appearance. If this is done the Committee will 
have opportunity to arrange their programs several weeks in advance of the meetings and 
the brethren who are members of the National Masonic Research Society will be better 
enabled to enter into the discussions after they have read over and studied the installment 
in THE BUILDER. 



REFERENCES FOR SUPPLEMENTAL PAPERS 


Immediately preceding each of Brother Haywood's monthly papers in the 
Correspondence Circle Bulletin will be found a list of references to THE BUILDER and 
Mackey's Encyclopedia. These references are pertinent to the paper and will either 
enlarge upon many of the points touched upon or bring out new points for reading and 
discussion. They should be assigned by the Committee to different brethren who may 
compile papers of their own from the material thus to be found, or in many instances the 
articles themselves or extracts therefrom may be read directly from the originals. The 
latter method may be followed when the members may not feel able to compile original 
papers, or when the original may be deemed appropriate without any alterations or 
additions. 


HOW TO ORGANIZE FOR AND CONDUCT THE STUDY MEETINGS 


The lodge should select a "Research Committee" preferably of three "live" members. 

The study meetings should be held once a month, either at a special meeting of the lodge 
called for the purpose, or at a regular meeting at which no business (except the lodge 
routine) should be transacted— all possible time to be given to the study period. 


After the lodge has been opened and all routine business disposed of, the Master should 
turn the lodge over to the Chairman of the Research Committee. This Committee should 
be fully prepared in advance on the subject for the evening. All members to whom 
references for supplemental papers have been assigned should be prepared with their 
papers and should also have a comprehensive grasp of Brother Haywood's paper. 


PROGRAM FOR STUDY MEETINGS 



1 . Reading of the first section of Brother Haywood's paper and the supplemental papers 
thereto. 


(Suggestion: While these papers are being read the members of the lodge should make 
notes of any points they may wish to discuss or inquire into when the discussion is 
opened. Tabs or slips of paper similar to those used in elections should be distributed 
among the members for this purpose at the opening of the study period.) 


2. Discussion of the above. 


3. The subsequent sections of Brother Haywood's paper and the supplemental papers 
should then be taken up, one at a time, and disposed of in the same manner. 


4. Question Box. 


MAKE THE "QUESTION BOX" THE FEATURE OF YOUR MEETINGS 


Invite questions from any and all brethren present. Let them understand that these 
meetings are for their particular benefit and get them into the habit of asking all the 
questions they may think of. Every one of the papers read will suggest questions as to 
facts and meanings which may not perhaps be actually covered at all in the paper. If at 
the time these questions are propounded no one can answer them, SEND THEM IN TO 
US. All the reference material we have will be gone through in an endeavor to supply a 
satisfactory answer. In fact we are prepared to make special research when called upon, 
and will usually be able to give answers within a day or two. Please remember, too, that 
the great Library of the Grand Lodge of Iowa is only a few miles away, and, by order of 
the Trustees of the Grand Lodge, the Grand Secretary places it at our disposal on any 
query raised by any member of the Society. 



FURTHER INFORMATION 


The foregoing information should enable local Committees to conduct their lodge study 
meetings with success. However, we shall welcome all inquiries and communications 
from interested brethren concerning any phase of the plan that is not entirely clear to 
them, and the Services of our Study Club Department are at the command of our 
members, lodge and study club committees at all times. 


QUESTIONS ON "THE LION’S PAW" 


What does the article in Mackey's Encyclopedia have to say concerning the Lion's Paw? 
What is the substance of Mackey's article on "The Lion of the Tribe of Judah"? 


Why has the lion always been a favourite subject with symbolists? What was the 
symbolism of the lion among early peoples in India? Of what was it a symbol to the Nile 
dwellers? Give an example of the use of the lion symbolism in Egyptian sculpture. How 
does Harrison describe the raising of Osiris? 


What was the crux ansata, or "ansated cross" originally? In what manner did it develop 
into the "Symbol of life" ? What did Albert Pike see in the crux ansata? 


How was the lion as a symbol used by the Jews? Where is it supposed that the Comacine 
Masters derived their habitual use of the lion in their cathedral building? What has 
Leader Scott to say concerning the lion in architecture? What is Brother Haywood's 
theory as to how the symbolism of the Lion's Paw came into Masonry? 


What power did the people of the cathedral building period believe the lioness to 
possess? Of what was this a symbol to them ? 



Of what did the early Freemasons consider the lion a symbol? 


Is there any difference between the real meaning of the symbolism of the Lion's Paw as 
interpreted by Albert Pike and as interpreted by Leader Scott? 


Does the symbol refer to a raising in this life, or in a future life? 


SUPPLEMENTAL REFERENCES 


THE BUILDER: 


Vol. II. - The Square and the Cross, p. 52. Vol III. - Egyptian Cross, p. 355. Vol. IV. - 
The Lion of the Tribe of Judah, p. 295. Vol. VI. - Symbolism of the Lion's Paw, Nov. C. 
- ,B„ p. 4. 


Mackey's Encyclopedia: Crux Ansata, p. 191; Lion's Paw, p.448; Lion of the Tribe of 
Judah, p. 802. 


THIRD STEPS BY BRO. H.L. HAYWOOD, IOWA 


PART VII-THE LION'S PAW 



The Mackey Encyclopedia article on this subject is very brief, as may be seen from the 
following: "A mode of recognition so called because of the rude resemblance made by 
the hand and fingers to a lion's paw. It refers to the 'Lion of the tribe of Judah.'" This is 
true as far as it goes, but it doesn't go far enough, for it leaves unanswered the questions 
of origin and interpretation. Nor does the companion article on the "Lion of the Tribe of 
Judah" give us much more information. If Mackey refrained from saying more because 
he knew no more we can sympathize with him, seeing that at this late day there is still 
very little known about the matter. But we have learned something since Mackey wrote, 
enough maybe, to set us on the track toward a satisfactory understanding of the matter. 


Owing to its appeal to the imagination, and to the fear and reverence it has ever aroused, 
the lion has always been a favourite with symbolists, especially religious symbolists. Our 
modem anthropologists and folk-lore experts have furnished us with numberless 
examples of this, even among savages, who are sometimes found worshipping the animal 
at this day. Among the early peoples of India the lion was often used, and generally with 
the same significance, as standing for "the divine spirit in man." Among the early 
Egyptians it was still more venerated as may be learned from their monuments, their 
temples, and especially their sphinxes; if we may trust our authorities in the matter the 
Nile dwellers used it as a symbol of the life-giving power of the sun and the sun's ability 
to bring about the resurrection of vegetation in the spring time. In some of the sculpture 
left by the Egyptians to illustrate the rites of the Egyptian Mysteries the candidate is 
shown lying on a couch shaped like a lion from which he is being raised from the dead 
level to a living perpendicular. The bas-reliefs at Denderah make this very plain, though 
they represent the god Osiris being raised instead of a human candidate. "Here," writes J. 
E. Harrison in her very interesting little book on "Ancient Art and Ritual," "the God is 
represented first as a mummy swathed and lying flat on his bier. Bit by bit he is seen 

raising himself up in a series of gymnastically impossible positions, till he rises all but 

erect, between the outstretched wings of Isis, while before him a male figure holds the 
crux ansata, the 'cross with a handle,' the Egyptian symbol of life." 


The crux ansata was, as Miss Harrison truly says, the symbol of life. Originally a stick, 
with a cross-piece at the top for a handle, it was used to measure the overflow of the 
Nile. Inasmuch as it was this overflow that carried fertility into Egypt, the idea of a life 
giving power gradually became transferred to the instrument itself; in the same manner 
that we attribute to a writer's "pen" his ability to use words. A few of our Masonic 
expositors, among whom Albert Pike may be numbered, have seen in the crux ansata the 
first form of that Lion's Paw by which the Masonic Homs is raised. If this be the case, 



the Lion's Paw is a symbol of life-giving power, an interpretation which fits in very well 
with our own position as outlined in the two preceding sections. 


But it is also possible to trace the Lion's Paw to another source. Among the Jews the lion 
was sometimes used as the emblem of the Tribe of Judah; as the Messiah was expected 
to spring from that tribe the Lion was also made to refer to him, as may be seen in the 
fifth verse of the fifth chapter of the Book of Revelation, where Jesus Christ is called the 
"Lion of the Tribe of Judah." It was from this source, doubtless, that the Comacines, the 
great Cathedral Builders of the Middle Ages, who were always so loyal to the Scriptures, 
derived their habitual use of the lion in their sculptures. Of this, Leader Scott, the great 
authority on the Comacines, writes that "My own observations have led me to the 
opinion that in Romanesque or Transition architecture, i.e. between A. D. 1000 and 
1200, the lion is to be found between the columns and the arch - the arch resting upon it. 
In Italian Gothic, i.e. from A. D. 1200 to 1500, it is placed beneath the column. In either 
position its significance is evident. In the first, it points to Christ as the door of the 
church. In the second, to Christ, the pillar of faith, springing from the tube of Judah." 
Since the cathedral builders were in all probability the first Freemasons it seems clear 
that the lion symbolism was inherited from the Comacines. 


During the cathedral building period, when symbolism was flowering out on all sides in 
medieval life, the lion was one of the most popular figures in the common animal 
mythology, as may be learned from Physiologers, the old book in which that mythology 
has been preserved. According to this record, the people believed that the whelps of the 
lioness were bom dead and that at the end of three days the lion would howl above them 
until they were awakened into life. In this the childlike people saw a symbol of Christ's 
resurrection after He had lain dead three days in the tomb; from this it naturally resulted 
that the lion came to be used as a symbol of the Resurrection, and such is the 
significance of the picture of a lion howling above the whelps, so often found in the old 
churches and cathedrals. 


The early Freemasons, so the records show, read both these meanings, Christ and 
Resurrection, into the symbol as they used it. And when we consider that all 
Freemasonry was Christian in belief down at least to the Grand Lodge era, we may be 
certain that the lion symbol is one of the vestiges of that early belief carried over into the 
modem system. If this be the case the Lion's Paw has the same meaning, whether we 
interpret it, with Pike, as an Egyptian symbol, or with Leader Scott, as a Christian 



emblem, as it stands for the life-giving power, a meaning that perfectly accords with its 
use in the Third degree. This also brings it into harmony with our interpretation of 
Eternal Life, for in both its Egyptian and its Christian usages it refers to a raising up to 
life in this world, and not to a raising in the world to come. 


SYMBOLISM OF THE LION’S PAW 


To explain clearly the symbol of the Lion's Paw, as it relates to Masonry, is a difficult 
matter. Mackey terms it a symbol of recognition, so-called because of the rude 
resemblance made by the hand and fingers to a lion's paw. 


The emblem of the Lion's Paw was found in the sarcophagus of one of the great kings of 
Egypt, entombed in the Pyramid erected to his everlasting remembrance. It brings to 
mind the representation of the king's initiation into those greater mysteries of Osiris held 
to be the highest aim of the wise and devout Egyptian. It is claimed by some writers that 
the Hebrews were probably instructed in the legend of Osiris, and afterwards changed 
the whole to accord with the wonderful and wise Solomon and his master architect 
Hiram. 


Very many Craftsmen reject the death of Hiram only as a myth. 


The emblem may be thus explained. The form that lies dead before the altar is that of 
Osiris, the personified sun god, whom the candidate represents in the drama of raising, 
lying dead at the winter solstice, slain by the grim Archer in November, the fatal month 
in the year of the sun. The figure of the lion grasping the dead sun god alludes to the 
constellation of Leo, which did prevail 4,000 years ago to raise the sun god to his place 
of power and glory on the summit of the grand royal arch of heaven at the summer 
solstice, and denoted then, as it does now, that the sun or the candidate is about to be 
raised from a symbolical death to life and power by the strong grip of the Lion's Paw; or, 
as it has been termed, "the lion of the tribe of Judah." The cross, which the lion holds in 
his other paw, is the ancient Egyptian symbol of eternal life. The figure erect at the altar 
is doubtless that of the grand hierophant, with his hand raised in an attitude of command, 



forming a right angle, with eyes fixed on the emblematic lion as he gives the sign of 
command that Osiris, or the candidate, be raised from death and darkness to light and 
life. 


It cannot be determined who Osiris was, but he was certainly to the Egyptians what 
Jupiter was to the Greeks. It is even difficult to determine whether the legend as 
recorded in mythology is reliable and authentic, but the lessons sought to be conveyed is 
the triumph of good over evil or light over darkness. 


If we view the scene that has just been described we see an exact representation of an 
instance that occurs in the making of every Craftsman. He may look upon the form as 
somewhat inconsistent, but a little study will show him that it was quite the reverse, and 
that his part was enacted by the devout Egyptian in the days of the most remote antiquity. 


The story of the sun starting in weakness and ending in victory, waging a long warfare 
against darkness, clouds and storms, and scattering them all in the end, is the story of all 
heroism, of all patient sacrifices and of all Christian devotion. 


If there is monotony in the thought of the daily toil of the sun for beings weaker than 
himself, of his wrath as he bides his face behind the dark cloud, of his vengeance as he 
tramples on the vapours which crowd around him at his setting, of the doom which 
severs him from the dawn at the beginning of his journey to restore her at its close, then 
there is monotony also in the bare record of birth and love, and toil and death, to which 
all human life may be pared down, 


To show that the Lion's Paw had reference to the sun, I refer to a form in the mysteries of 
Hindoostan. While performing a ceremony the candidate was taught to exclaim, on his 
arrival each time in the South, "I copy the example of the sun and follow his benevolent 
course." This being completed, he was again placed in the centre and solemnly enjoined 
to the practice of religious austerities, as the efficient means of preparing his soul for 
final absoiption. In the Mysteries of Bacchus the candidate was imprisoned in a pastos 
or cell. He was alarmed by a crash resembling the rush of waters bursting with sudden 



impetuosity from a deep abyss or the deadening fall of a tremendous cataract, for now 
was the representation displayed of the waters of the deluge breaking forth from Hades 
to inundate the globe. The monstrous Typhon, raging in quest of Osiris, discovered the 
ark in which he had been secreted, and violently rending it asunder, scattered the limbs 
of his victim over the face of the earth, amidst the din of dissolving nature. The aspirant 
heard the lamentations which were instituted for the death of their god, whose 
representative he was, accompanied with doleful cries and howlings of men, women and 
animals, to symbolize the death-shrieks and exclamations of terror, consternation and 
despair which prevailed throughout the world at the universal destruction of animated 
nature, and which would undoubtedly salute the ears of Noah while within the vessel of 
safety. Should we follow up the ceremonies of the various mysteries, we will find that in 
all instances the candidate passes from darkness to light, as personified in the Third 
degree. To ascertain at what period the Lion's Paw was introduced into Masonic ritual 
cannot be done; but this is nothing uncommon with our ancient Order. Even its origin is 
clouded in uncertainty. Associated with the Lion's Paw is a code or covenant called the 
Five Points of Fellowship. These five points, taken together, compose the Mason's 
creed. I cannot conceive any thing more binding, more humane and sympathetic than 
these five admonitions. They contain the fundamental principles of Freemasonry, and 
the brother that fully observes them is certainly the ideal Mason. 


A. J. Burton in "Freemasons Journal," May 17, 1888. 


Always remember what Masonry is, and what it stands for; remember that it is not a 
religion, but that it is a series of moral teachings, it points the way to man to a better and 
cleaner life; it broadens his knowledge of his duty to his God and to his fellow man; 
Masonry cannot make a man live better, but it puts within his grasp these moral precepts 
which, if he follows their literal meaning, will make him a better man, a better father, a 
better neighbor and a better Mason; there is no plausible reason for a Mason to go 
radically wrong; the greatest teachings ever written come from the Great Light in 
Masonry; a Mason has no excuse for not knowing what is right, fair and just in his 
actions toward his fellow man; many of us consider ourselves Masons because we have 
taken its degrees and are permitted to wear its symbol on our coat lapels, but that 
conception of it is as far from the truth as the East is from the West; a true Mason is a 
man; a man who is willing to make sacrifices of time, money and opportunity in behalf 
of mankind and the brother at his elbow. - Charles B. Eddy, P.G.M., Michigan 





No man can say that he has done his best if there even one more least thing he can do. - 
Stone. 


MASONS’ MARKS AND MARK MASONRY 


BY BRO CHARLES C. CONOVER, MICHIGAN 


THE SELECTION AND REGISTRATION OF “MARKS” WITH LAWS AND 
CUSTOMS RELATING THERETO 


MY ATTENTION was particularly attracted to this subject when I read the following 
article in the American Tyler-Key stone of Novembers 1915: 


“A Michigan companion was recently visiting in a neighboring state, and upon being 
examined was asked to show his Mark. He was unable to do so, never having complied 
with the instructions to select and register a Mark. He was somewhat at a loss to know just 
what the examining committee meant, and later made inquiry and was instructed. 


“Every companion is supposed to select and record a Mark that will identify him. The 
Mark should be engraved upon the watch charm or some token. Some Grand Chapters 
require that this should be done before a companion is exalted, but others trust to the 
companion following the instruction given, which many times is neglected, and the 
companion later on finds himself in an embarrassing position because of his failure to 
comply with the regulations. We wonder what percentage of Royal Arch Masons of 
Michigan have really selected and registered their Mark ?” 



I thought at the time that it was fortunate this matter had been brought to the attention of 
our Michigan companions, for some other jurisdictions are making strenuous efforts to 
have every brother Mark Master Mason select and record his “Mark,” and a good majority 
of Grand Jurisdictions have legislated that a brother cannot be advanced until he has 
selected his “Mark” and had it recorded with the Secretary. 


I find that nearly if not all Masonic Supply Houses furnish “Books of Marks” in various 
forms but showing a conventional keystone with the letters in the circle in the center of 
which each brother is expected to register his own particular mark (Fig. 1). One 
jurisdiction, Alberta, furnishes a printed blank form of size to fit an official envelope with 
spaces for name, number of chapter, date of M. M. M., and description of Mark. This 
blank is supplied to the candidate to make it as convenient as possible for him to select his 
Mark and forward it to the Secretary of the chapter for proper record in the Mark Book. 


Now it happens that all chapter Secretaries are not bom artists and many refrain from 
endeavoring to depict the intricate designs which some brothers see fit to choose; then 
again the Mark Mason himself may not be an artisan skilled in the use of a pen but might 
wield an axe with precision, so that it finally seems to narrow down to having the chapter 
select a companion who has the artisan temperament coupled with the necessary ambition 
to do the work. In the absence of all the above, it generally obtains that the requirement is 
entirely neglected. 


Many chapters, mine among the number, present each Mark Master with a “token” in the 
form of a “penny” which gives on the obverse the name, number and location of chapter, 
together with a conventional Royal Arch emblem; on the reverse a keystone with a space 
in the center for engraving the mark after it has been selected, but there it leaves the more 
or less mystified brother and when he is examined as to his proficiency for the Mark 
degree (if this is done at all) no question is asked as to whether he has selected and 
recorded his Mark. 


As a mle I find that foreign chapters give much more attention and care to selecting and 
recording of Marks than do the chapters of the United States. 



In order to get more definite information upon the various angles of this subject, I 
addressed a questionnaire to the Grand Secretary of each Grand Chapter of the world 
which contained the following: 

“I am preparing an article for the next Grand Chapter proceedings on the selection and 
recording of Marks by Mark-Master Masons. Will you please briefly answer these 
questions so far as they relate to your Grand Chapter: 


“1. Has any ruling been made as to what constitutes a Mark? 


“2. Does Grand Chapter require that the Mark shall be recorded previous to Royal Arch? 
“3. Are Mark Masons examined as to proficiency in Lecture before advancement? 


“4. 


Does the custom of presenting a 'Penny' to Mark Masters obtain among your chapters? 


“5. Has Grand Chapter legislated on No. 4? 


“6. Cite page and year of legislation on Marks in your proceedings, if any. 


“Any further information on the subject of Marks generally you can refer me to will be 
greatly appreciated.” 

Most of the Grand Secretaries were very courteous in answering promptly and supplying 
all the information asked. Armed with this information, I have arranged the replies in 
tabulated form which will at a glance, give the interested student a world survey of this 
interesting and important subject. 

*Mark Master degree not conferred in the Royal Arch Chapter, but controlled by Mark 
Lodges under Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons. 



CITATION TO REGULATIONS 


The following citations to constitutional or statutory provisions have been gathered which 
will give the reader a good general idea of the extent to which selection of Marks and 
proficiency in the degrees have had the attention of the several Grand Chapters: 


Alabama. - Whereas, The traditions of the Mark Master's degree made it obligatory and 
imperative upon every one, who has been advanced to this degree, to “choose for himself a 
Mark”; and 


Whereas, The Mark is not a mere ornamental appendage to the degree, but is a sacred 
token of the rites of friendship and brotherly love, and its presentation at any time by the 
owner to another Mark Master Mason, would claim for him certain acts of friendship 
which are of solemn obligation among the Fraternity, therefore 


Resolved, 1 st, That every Mark Master Mason in this Grand Jurisdiction be required to 
choose a Mark and record it in the Lodge Book of Marks, and that the R.\ W.\ Masters of 
the several Lodges of M.’.M.’. Masons, working under the Jurisdiction of this Grand 
Chapter, require each and every candidate, immediately after being advanced to the 
M.’.M.’. degree, to record his name and date of advancement in the “Lodge Book of 
Marks,” and inform him that, before he can receive the R.’.A.\ degree, he must complete 
the record by selecting and recording his Mark. 


Resolved, 2d, That it shall be the duty of the High Priest of each and every chapter in this 
Grand Jurisdiction, whenever a candidate is announced for the R.’.A.’. degree, to ascertain 
from the Secretary of the Chapter if such candidate has chosen his Mark and had same 
recorded in the “Book of Marks”; and that the R.’.A.’. degree shall not be conferred upon 
any candidate until such record is made. 



Resolved, Ed, That the Secretaries of the Subordinate Chapters, under this Grand 
Jurisdiction be required to furnish the Grand Secretary with the names and descriptions of 
the Marks chosen by the members of their respective chapters. 


Resolved, 4th, That the Grand Secretary of this Grand Chapter be required to keep in his 
office a book, in which shall be recorded the names and descriptions of all Mark Master's 
Marks in this Grand Jurisdiction. (Proc. 1899, p. 28.) 


Alberta. - Candidates for reception are examined in M. M. M. Lodge; candidates for 
exaltation are examined in M. E. M. Lodge. (Proc. 1919, p. 9.) 


Arkansas. - The Secretary of each subordinate chapter, in reporting exaltations occurring 
three months or more prior to the meeting of Grand Chapter, shall state whether each 
companion so exalted has recorded his Mark. The Grand Secretary shall immediately 
notify any companion delinquent in this jurisdiction that unless his Mark shall have been 
properly recorded within thirty days, he shall be subject to discipline by his subordinate 
chapter. (Proc. 1912, pp. 197, 205.) 


California. - Every Mark Master must select his Mark and record the same in the Book of 
Marks, kept by the chapter for that puipose; and no chapter shall confer the Royal Arch 
degree until this requirement has been complied with. (Con., sec. 136.) 


Connecticut. - Every chapter is hereby required to procure and keep with its records a 
Book of Marks. Hereafter no candidate shall be exalted within this jurisdiction until he 
shall have selected and caused to be recorded a Mark. (Constitution and Laws, Art. 2.) 


Delaware. - All Mark Masons are required to adopt a Mark, and have the same recorded in 
the Book of Marks, officers of subordinate chapters using all endeavors to have those who 
are at present members and who have not chosen for themselves a Mark, to do so. 
(Adopted Jan. 16, 1895.) 



Resolved, Hereafter all Marks must be recorded in the Lodge Book of Marks in ink, with a 
full description of same. (Proc. 1919, p. 78.) 


England. - By a resolution of the Grand Mark Lodge of England, on the 14th of December, 
1 864, the regulation confining speculative Masons' Marks to any specified number of 
points was abrogated. But straight lines are imperative. 


Florida. - Art. V., Sec. 2. A Book of Marks. Reg. 38. It is the duty of each chapter to 
maintain a suitable Book of Marks, and to require every member and all candidates, after 
receiving the Mark Master's degree, to select and have recorded a suitable “Mark” therein, 
The Royal Arch degree shall not be conferred until the “Mark” is selected and recorded, 
unless it be done at a Grand visitation by the Grand High Priest, in which case the matter 
of the “Mark” should be attended to as soon as possible thereafter. (Con. 1919, p. 25.) 


General Grand Chapter. - In case of a Mark, constructed in part of “initials per a certain 
key,” inscribed correctly as to instructions, but incorrectly as to intention, through 
erroneous explanation of the key by the High Priest: Held that the intention should prevail, 
and the inscription be made to comply therewith. (Pro. 1897, pp. 42, 173.) 


Illinois. - 267. It shall be the duty of every chapter to provide itself with a Book of Marks 
which shall be on the Secretary's desk whenever the Mark Master's degree is conferred. 


268. Every Mark Master is expected to select and record a Mark before receiving the 
Royal Arch degree, and when once chosen and recorded as such in the Lodge Book of 
Marks no one can alter or change it. If erased or changed on the book, such action being 
illegal, does not thereby alter or change the Mark, which remains as originally selected and 
recorded, and the Secretary of the chapter should cause its restoration on the book. 



269. It is not necessary for a Mark Master to engrave with his own hand his chosen Mark 
upon the Lodge Book of Marks, but it may be done by another with his approval. 
(Constitution, Secs. 267, 268, 269.) 


Indiana. - Resolved, That in no case shall any candidate receive the Royal Arch degree 
until he has adopted and filed with the Secretary of his chapter a copy of the Mark he is 
obliged to adopt; that a petition for affiliation shall be accompanied by a copy of the Mark 
of the applicant, and that no demit shall be issued to any companion who has not 
previously selected a Mark and had the same recorded. (Proc. 191 1, p. 79.) 


Iowa. - Sec. 122. Every chapter in this jurisdiction shall keep a Book of Marks, in which 
shall be entered the Mark of every member advanced to the honorary degree of Mark 
Master; and every member so advanced is required to select a Mark and have it entered in 
said Book of Marks before he receives the Royal Arch degree. (Constitution and Laws.) 


Ireland. - In Ireland there are no definite rules, and the Marks are accepted just as they are 
sent in. No attention is paid practically to the matter, and not one Mark Mason in twenty 
adopts a Mark of any kind. Those who do frequently select designs quite unsuitable for the 
puipose, such as crests or monograms, but they are all registered in Grand Chapter books 
without question. 


Kansas. - Sec. 81. No candidate shall be exalted until he shall have selected his Mark and 
caused it to be recorded in the Lodge Book of Marks. (By-laws.) 


Resolved, That the High Priests of the various chapters in this jurisdiction be directed to 
require that all members of their respective chapters who have heretofore failed to select 
and record their Marks do so without further delay. (Standing Regulation, 1892, p. 502.) 


Resolved, That the Grand Lecturer be directed to examine the Book of Marks of any 
chapter visited by him, and report to the Grand High Priest and the Grand Chapter every 



non-compliance with the Grand Chapter By-laws referring to the selection and recording 
of Marks. (Standing Regulation, Proc. 1892, p. 502.) 


When a companion joins a chapter on demit, he should record his Mark in the Lodge Book 
of Marks, if it has not been recorded where he previously held membership. (Laws of 
1907, p. 102.) 


Kentucky. - Reg. 498. The “Mark” is a pledge in seeking relief, not for ordinary loans. 


Reg. 499. Recording a “Mark” must be done before the Royal Arch can be conferred. 
(Grand Chapter Regulations.) 


Maine. - No candidate shall be advanced to the Royal Arch degree until he shall have 
selected a Mark and presented it to the Secretary for record. (Digest, p. 196.) 


Maryland. - 3. All chapters are required to procure and keep Mark Books for the registry 
of the Marks of their respective members. The registry shall include copy of Mark, with 
description. No candidate shall be exalted to the degree of Royal Arch who has not 
previously recorded his Mark. 


4. No candidate shall be exalted, unless by dispensation, until he has made sufficient 
proficiency in the preceding degrees to satisfy the Council that he can make himself 
known in those degrees. The examination as to proficiency to be had in open M.’.E.’. 
Master's Lodge, (regulations.) 


Michigan. - It is not necessary for the High Priest to require Mark Masters to choose a 
Mark and have the same recorded. (Proc. 1898, p. 14.) 



Minnesota. - Resolved, That all High Priests; be obliged under the law to see that all 
candidates be required to record their Marks before exaltation to the Royal Arch degree; 
and that High Priests use their best endeavors to have all companions whose Marks are not 
yet recorded attend to this duty at their earliest convenience. (Proc. 1903, p. 20.) 


Mississippi. - Ritual requirements only. 


Missouri. - Only requirements are in the ritual. 


Montana. - Proficiency in lecture refers to proficiency in grips and words; practically no 
other examination. (Gd. Sec.) 


Sec. 3. It shall be the duty of every member of this chapter, within six months from the 
date of his exaltation, to select his Mark and cause the same to be recorded in the Book of 
Marks. (Cons, and By-laws, 1892, p. 26.) 


Resolved, That the Secretary of each chapter in this jurisdiction, be required to secure, so 
far as possible, the signature to the roll book and the Mark of each companion who has 
ever been a member of his chapter, and that the incoming Grand High Priest inquire into 
the fulfillment of this recommendation and report. (Proc. 1914, p. 28.) 


Nebraska. - Before advancement, each candidate shall prove himself to be a skilful 
workman as a Master Mason, by an examination before the Council; and as a Mark Master 
and Most Excellent Master in open lodge to the entire satisfaction of the chapter in which 
he seeks advancement, by examination in the degrees last conferred. 


No Mark Master shall be exalted to the Royal Arch degree until his Mark is recorded. 
(Const, and Bylaws, Chap. 110, 1906.) 



Nevada. - Every Mark Master Mason attached to a chapter under this jurisdiction, must, 
before his exaltation, select his Mark and record the same in the Book of Marks kept by 
the chapter for that purpose. And every candidate for affiliation must in like manner record 
his Mark before being permitted to sign the bylaws; and it is made the duty of the 
Secretary of each chapter to see that this regulation is complied with. (Gen. Reg., Sec. 2.) 


Proficiency. That the subordinate chapters under our jurisdiction be, and they are hereby 
recommended not to confer any degree in Capitular Masonry until the candidate has 
become proficient in the preceding degrees of Masonry, and especially that he be found 
thoroughly conversant with the first sections of the Entered Apprentice, Fellow Craft, and 
Master Masons' degrees, and with all the means of recognition practiced among Master 
Masons, to be ascertained by a committee or otherwise. (Proc. 1878, p. 135.) 


New Jersey. - Sec. 20. No Mark Master Mason shall be exalted to the Royal Arch degree 
in this jurisdiction until he shall have chosen his particular Mark, and have delivered a 
representative of the same for record to the chapter in which he was advanced. 


Sec. 43. It is the duty of the Secretary of the chapter under the direction of the High Priest, 
to ascertain from the Shook of Marks, that no Mark bearing the same device as that 
offered, has previously been recorded; and to refuse to record a duplicate of any Mark 
already recorded in the Lodge Book of Marks, except as provided in Sec. 53. 


Sec. 44. It is incumbent upon subordinate chapters to require candidates to memorize the 
lectures and pass examination thereon in open lodge before exaltation. 


Sec. 53. A Mark Master Mason may select as his Mark any design he may wish not 
previously selected by another. If the Mark so to be selected be inscribed upon a jewel or a 
badge, bearing the Mark of a deceased brother, and shall come to the brother as a gift or an 
inheritance, it may be adopted as his own particular Mark by such Mark Master Mason; 
provided, it be actually in his possession, unincumbered by pledge. (Const. 1905.) 



New York. - Sec. 52. 4. A Book of Marks, in which shall be recorded the Marks of the 
members. It shall be the duty of each member of a chapter to choose a Mark, and to 
furnish the Secretary with a copy or description thereof. This duty is incumbent on all who 
have not previously selected and had recorded their Marks in the Lodge Book of Marks. A 
pictorial description is not obligatory. A written description on the page set apart for the 
member shall be sufficient. The Mark of a Mark Master Mason must be selected and 
recorded before the Royal Arch degree is conferred upon him. 


A duly recorded Mark cannot be altered or changed, and, during the lifetime of the owner, 
must not be chosen by another member of the same chapter. If a companion changes his 
membership, his Mark remains as a matter of record with the mother chapter, but a copy 
thereof may be placed on record in the Book of Marks belonging to the chapter with which 
he subsequently affiliates, due reference being made to the original record. 


Sec. 75. No candidate shall be exalted until he has exhibited suitable proficiency in the 
preceding degrees. (Con., Secs. 52, 75.) 


New Zealand. - Only the ritual construction, viz.: Three, five, seven, or any other odd 
number of lines, or salient points joined by lines, the equilateral triangle always excepted. 
(Gd. Scribe E.) 


North Dakota. - Each subordinate chapter under this jurisdiction is required to keep a 
“Book of Marks,” in which shall be entered the Mark of every brother advanced to the 
honorary degree of a Mark Master Mason, and every brother so advanced is hereby 
required to select a Mark, and have it recorded in said “Book of Marks,” before being 
exalted to the sublime degree of a Royal Arch Mason. (By-Laws, Sec. 24, p. 28.) 


That the use of monograms, initials, or the given or surnames, in whole or in part, of a 
Mark Master Mason as his Mark, selected by him to be placed in the Book of Marks, be 
prohibited; that the report of the subordinate chapters to the Grand Chapter be so arranged 



as to include therein the remark that each Mark Master Mason passed, had selected his 
Mark prior to receiving the degree of Royal Arch, and that the same had been duly 
recorded in the Lodge Book of Marks. (Pro. 1904, p. 154.) 


A candidate for advancement must have sufficient knowledge of the preceding degree to 
make himself well known. (By-laws, Sec. 28, p. 27.) 


Nova Scotia. - It is competent for a companion to select as his own, the Mark of a 
deceased companion. (Pro. 1899, p. 16.) 


Ohio. - Sec. 25, p. 95. The petitioners for a new chapter, and the candidates advanced in it 
to the degree of Mark Master whilst such new chapter is working under a dispensation, 
have the right, respectively, to choose a Mark, and have the same recorded in the Mark 
Book of such new chapter, and those of the petitioners who had before that time chosen 
Marks and had them recorded elsewhere, may also have them recorded in the Mark Book 
of such new chapter. 


Sec. 25, p. 98. It is the duty of each chapter to keep a suitable Mark Book, and keep 
therein a record of the Marks of its members. 


In no case shall any candidate receive the Royal Arch degree until he has adopted and filed 
with the Secretary of his chapter a copy of the Mark he is obligated to adopt. (Pro. 191 1, p. 
46.) 


Sec. I, p. 51. All the degrees of the chapter except the Royal Arch may be conferred on a 
candidate on the same day. Two special meetings may be called and all degrees may be 
conferred. 



Before a charter for such new chapters shall be granted by Grand Chapter, that certificates 
of the High Priests and Secretaries, under seal, of the various chapters of which the 
petitioning companions are members, should be filed with the Grand Secretary, showing 
that the requirements of selecting and registering the companion's Mark, have been 
complied with. (Pro. 1919, p. 53.) 


Pennsylvania. - There is no published ruling as to what constitutes a Mark in this 
jurisdiction, but before a Mark Master Mason may be exalted to the degree of Roval Arch 
Mason, he must adopt as his Mark a device to be engraved upon a hard substance, within a 
circle, surrounded by letters with which you are familiar and within the lines of a keystone, 
the said Mark must be recorded in a Book of Marks which every chapter is required to 
keep. (Grand Secretary Wells.) 


Rhode Island. - Every brother, before being exalted to the sublime degree of the Royal 
Arch, should adopt a Mark and have the same properly recorded. (Pro. 1906, p. 8.) 


Scotland. - The writer has had considerable correspondence with Grand Scribe E. Murray 
who has edited a “Memorandum on Marks” which was submitted to the Grand Chapter for 
its approval. This is the most comprehensive treatment of the subject I have seen and I 
have Companion Murray's permission to reproduce such portions as desired, for which he 
has our grateful thanks. 


MEMORANDUM IN REGARD TO INTERPRETATION OF INSTRUCTIONS FOR 
THE MAKING OF MARKS 


A clear statement has frequently been requested as to the exact rules governing the form of 
Marks. In particular, a prominent chapter has specially asked to be provided with a definite 
rule. In consequence the following Memorandum was submitted to Supreme Grand 
Committee for the puipose of information so that they might consider the subject and, if so 
advised, give an official ruling on the meaning of the instructions for the degree. The 
matter was remitted to a special Sub-Committee on Marks, and in the interval the 
Memorandum has been revised and corrected. 



In Ireland there are no definite rules, and the Marks are accepted just as they are sent in. 

No attention is paid practically to the matter, and not one Mark Mason in twenty adopts a 
Mark of any kind. Those who do frequently select designs quite unsuitable for the puipose, 
such as crests or monograms, but they are all registered in Grand Chapter books without 
question. 


I am informed that by a resolution of the Grand Mark Lodge of England, on 14th 
December, 1 864, the regulation confining speculative Masons' Marks to any specified 
number of points was abrogated. But straight lines are imperative. 


In America, so far as can be ascertained, there is no rule specifying what should be 
selected as a Mark, this being left entirely to the candidate himself to determine. 


The Grand Lodge of Scotland has never, so far as can be ascertained, laid down any rule 
whatever, and disclaims any responsibility for any ritual on the subject. 


The way, therefore, appears to be quite open to this committee to suggest a definite ruling 
for themselves, and to let others follow it or not as they choose. 


The instructions as they stand at present substantially consist of a direction that any Mark 
adopted by a candidate and member must consist of any number of odd points connected 
by lines, with the exception of one special figure containing three points. The old 
manuscript copy of the working, in the possession of Supreme Grand Chapter, says, “3, 5, 
7, 9, or 1 1 points joined together to form any figure they pleased except, etc.” It may be 
interesting to add, in parenthesis, that according to the old independent Yorkshire working 
early last century, the members present had also to be 3, 5, 7, 9, etc., and the fee was “one 
mark, Is 1 l/2d., neither more nor less.” 



The theory held by some is that the Mark was, and is still supposed to be, made by the 
workman with the edge of a chisel, not by its comer point, so that each stroke therefore 
will make nothing but a straight line. This would apply to the Mark on the blade of the 
chisel, but I should rather think the Mark cut on a stone would be made by a pointed 
chisel, and therefore that so far it would be conveniently possible to form a curved figure. 
As the Mark was reproduced on the hewn stones, it should have been the same as that 
which was struck on the blade of the Mason's own tools to identify them in the boxes, or 
when returned from shaipening, or for any other necessary puiposes. 

While the actual words of the instructions do not expressly say “straight” lines, this is 
commonly understood to be implied. The old ritual of Chapter Esk, No. 42, however, 
expressly says, “straight or curved lines.” There may be others giving the same reading. 


Among the operative Masons of Scotland for centuries genuine curved Marks are by no 
means unknown, but are very few. For instance, at Fortrose Cathedral out of 265 Marks 
there is only one with curved lines (representing a vessel). A heart is also an emblem not 
uncommon. But, on the whole, out of the many thousand specimens from the thirteenth 
century downwards, it is almost unusual to find a Mark with curved lines.... 


The speculative Masons are lineal descendants of the Operative Craft, though not the only 
branch, and theoretically they are subject to the same mles of work and inteipretation as 
the body from which they sprang. 


The first question which arises is as to the regulation about the number of points. This 
regulation may hold with the present speculative system, but it has nothing whatever to do 
with King Solomon's Temple, where not a single Mason's Mark has ever been found. 
Indeed, there are no Mason's Marks on any known historic and ancient Jewish building, or 
at least if so I am not aware of it. The story about a Mark of approval made by an 
equilateral triangle and about juxtaposition Marks is apocryphal. The regulation has no 
sanction or foundation in the practice of the Operative Craft. 


No system of counting will ever prove that such a rule existed operatively. Numberless 
specimens prove the contrary. 



There used to be a story current in the Craft some thirty years ago that there was a 
distinction between the Mark of a Fellow of Craft and that of a Master Mason, the former 
having an even number of points and the latter an odd number. The idea was a fad of some 
theorists and had no foundation in fact, except that when the agreement between the Grand 
Lodge of Scotland and the Supreme Grand Chapter of Scotland regarding the Mark degree 
was entered into, it evidently ignored the fact that the Mark Man and the Mark Master 
were two separate degrees - the former worked after the second degree and the latter after 
the third. But the Mark was chosen by the Mark Man, and the indiscriminate use of any 
number of points for a Mark, odd or even, is therefore, according to the basis of the theory 
mentioned, correct. Incidentally, it may be added that the part of our present ritual 
referring to the infliction of the penalty is incorrectly expressed. It was the Entered 
Apprentice who suffered, because he had no Mark to present, not the Fellowcraft, who 
presented his own Mark. It is absurd to suppose that he suffered because he used the 
triangle instead of his proper Mark. The American ritual I have seen solves this difficulty 
by making the Mark Master present and withdraw his hand in a different way to that of his 
workmen. 


Assuming, however, that the rule according to the ritual is to be observed, a difficulty 
arises as to what precisely is meant by a point which has to be counted. The instruction is 
that the Mark must have a certain number of odd points connected by straight lines. Now 
every straight line consists of an innumerable number of points. Logically, therefore, the 
definition means and implies that every point in a straight line is not to be counted solely 
because it is in that line. Any point to be counted must be selected for some other reason. 
Now, according to the definition, it is quite clear that the end points of a straight line must 
be and are intended to be counted because they are the points which are connected by a 
straight line. It is therefore beyond question that any point which is the beginning, or 
ending, of one or more straight lines must be a point to be counted according to the rules 
of the degree. 


The difficulty arises as to the counting when two straight lines intersect, or rather when 
they not merely intersect but cross one another. In such a case is the point of intersection 
a point within the meaning of the instructions for the degree? Varying opinions have for 
the past half-century been held among Freemasons about this, but the old records rather 
support the rule that a mere intersection or crossing does not constitute a point. The point 
is and must be the end of a line and not merely a part of it in the middle. (Fig. 3). 



On the footing of odd points only being counted, this consists of four points and is 
wrong, “O” being a point, while Fig. 4 is right and consists of five points, “O” being a 
point at the end of both e separate and distinct lines - CO and OD. On the other hand, a 
prominent member of the Scottish Craft holds that O is not a point in either case, because 
in both illustrations it is wiped out as such by being merged in the line AB. He holds that 
a point must be a salient point, either acute or obtuse, or the free end of a line. 


Again Fig. 5 is right and consists of five points, A, B. C, D and O. Take another example, 
Fig. 6, this is wrong because it consists of four points, both ends of the line OC requiring 
to be counted. It is on the same footing as if the figure were one like Fig. 7. Fig. 8, which 
has been submitted, is evidently wrong, because on any system of counting, intersections 
or not, it contains an even number of points. 


The following series of figures is given (Fig. 9) as an instance of common Marks some of 
which were undoubtedly used by operatives, but which according to a strict reading of the 
ritual, odd points only, would appear to be improper. 


For illustrations of old operative Marks reference may be made to the historical examples 
to be found in the Mark Book now under issue by the Supreme Grand Chapter. 
(Companion Murray has sent this writer a copy of this volume.) 


In the petition to Lodge Mother Kilwinning in 1677, of which the Warrant to Lodge 
Canongate Kilwinning was granted, nine out of the twelve petitioners append their Marks. 
They are all composed of straight lines connected together. If the crossings are not 
counted, there were 8 even and 1 odd. If crossings are counted, there were 3 even and 6 
odd. One of them was even and had no crossing point. 


In the first minute-book of the Lodge of Edinburgh, if crossings are not counted, about 
two-thirds of the Marks are odd and the remaining one-third even. If crossings are 
counted, there is a slight preponderance of odd points. 



In the Mark Book of Chapter Edinburgh for the first fifty years or so, if crossings are not 
counted, there are 33 odd and 40 even. If crossings are counted, the same proportion 
remains. But 134 out of 233 Marks transgress the rule that straight lines only must be 
counted. The use of curved lines has, however, in this case ceased for several decades. As 
in the case of the Roman Eagle Lodge, when the Mark degree was introduced in 1785, a 
large number of the transgressing Marks are not Marks at all, but representations of 
Masonic symbols and emblems such as the hive, the irradiated sun, the ladder, the skull 
and cross-bones, the heart, and so on. 

There are Jewish and other letters, a hand grasping an arrow, or a sword, or a pen, or a 
musket. There is a horse vaulting a gate, and a lion passant, a clam shell, a stag's head, a 
man in the moon, a haip, the volume of the sacred law, an irradiated star, and a laurel 
branch, etc., all drawn illustratively. There are also several Marks with points alone and 
no lines at all. There are also instances of, say a shield with a triangle or a cross, or some 
entirely separate figure within it. Latterly, it is only too common to find puerile attempts 
to combine initials. 


I contribute illustrations of the Marks in the Roman Eagle Lodge Minute Book (Fig. 10), 
and of those found in Culross Abbey, (Fig. 11). 


A sheet of operative Marks from the Queen Street Garden Walls, within a short distance of 
the Seat of Supreme Grand Chapter, is also appended for illustration (Fig. 12). These may 
be taken to be about 100 years old. 


To sum up, the main points for decision are: 


1 . Whether a “point” (a mere dot) can be counted if it is shown alone and not as part of a 
line. 


2. Whether a point means the end of a separate and distinct line or a free salient angle. 



3. Whether the lines must be straight or may be curved. 


4. Whether the lines must all be connected or whether they may be disconnected as, for 
example, a triangle within a shield, or dots or a small or large circle. 


5. Whether the points must be odd in number. 


6. Whether in this case a crossing point must be counted. 


7. Whether in the same case a crossing point need not be counted unless desired, and, if 
one is counted, must all in the same figure be counted. 


8. Whether the points may be odd or even in number. In this case it is not necessary to 
trouble about crossing points, because they can make no difference to the ultimate result. 


As a closing remark it ought to be added that, looking to the number of different Marks 
required for the large number of members now being admitted, if any mere point of 
intersection is allowed to be counted it will make it greatly easier to multiply the available 
number of possible Marks. If such a point of mere intersection is not to be counted and is 
ruled out, the number of available Marks with a reasonable number of lines will be cut 
down probably by onefourth. This is admittedly an argument ad convenientiam, but in 
certain cases expediency rises to the height of principle. 


RULING 



The rule suggested is simply that all Marks in future must be composed of straight lines 
joined together, and the counting of points be discontinued. 


If this rule be adopted no further question can apparently arise, and the simplicity of the 
rule is greatly in its favour. It would involve, however, that the ritual should be subject to a 
slight correction to bring it into conformity with the rule, but this can easily be done. 

24th May, 1919. 

A. A. MURRAY. 

Revised 18th September, 1919. 


South Carolina. - 1 beg to acknowledge the receipt of your letter, and am much interested 
to know that you are preparing an article on the selection and recording of Marks, by Mark 
Masters. I trust that you will favor us with a copy of this address, for I am much interested 
in the general subject, and our Grand High Priest is of the opinion that some sort of 
legislation is needed in our own Grand Chapter upon the subject. 


I return your questionnaire herewith, and have endeavored to make general answers to the 
interrogatories therein propounded. It is somewhat difficult for us to answer with simple 
yes or no, however, for we have always thought that the matter of Marks was a subject for 
General Grand Chapter laws, and did not know that different customs obtain in the various 
jurisdictions with reference to the selection and recording of Marks. 


I can find no law or ruling upon the subject in the minutes of our Grand Chapter, and the 
answers are therefore based upon the general doctrine that obtains among us in South 
Carolina, which I have never heard questioned by any one. (Grand Secretary Hart.) 


Tennessee. - Article 24, Sec. 1. Every Mark Master attached to a chapter must select his 
Mark and record the same in a book of Marks kept by the chapter for that puipose, and the 
degree of Royal Arch Mason shall not be conferred upon any brother until he shall have 
thus selected and recorded his Mark. (Pro. 1915, p.71.) 



The law concerning the recording of Marks is only obligatory one time, and that in the 
chapter where the companion receives the Mark Master's degree. If a companion desires to 
record his Mark which he selected when he took the Mark Master's degree, in the Book of 
Marks of the chapter with which he may thereafter affiliate, he may do so; but it is a matter 
of courtesy and not a matter of law that he be permitted to do so; otherwise we concur in 
the ruling of the Most Excellent Grand High Priest. (Pro. 1915, p. 86.) 


Texas. - Mark Masters have six months in which to select their Marks. (Grand Secretary 
Bartley.) 


Utah. - Sec. 85. No candidate shall be exalted to the degree of Royal Arch Mason until he 
shall have chosen his Mark and the same has been recorded, and every constituent chapter 
is required to keep a proper Book of Marks in which shall be recorded the Mark of each 
and all its members. (Pro. 1919, p. 28.) 


Vermont. - 1. That every chapter be and is hereby, required to procure and keep with its 
records a Book of Marks. 


II. That hereafter no candidate shall be exalted within this jurisdiction until he shall have 
selected and caused to be recorded a Mark. 


ITT. The High Priests are hereby directed to require all members of their respective 
chapters, who have not previously done so, to select and record their Marks, and that 
report of all companions in this jurisdiction who have neglected or refused to comply with 
these resolutions be made to the Grand Secretary. (Pro. 1889, p. 24.) 


Victoria. - No Marks are used in the Grand Chapter of Victoria for the reason that Mark 
Masonry is not made a part of Royal Arch Masonry but is under a separate constitution. A 



Master Mason may become a Royal Arch companion without having advanced to the 
degree of a Mark Master Mason, but as a rule a Mason belongs to a Craft Lodge, a Mark 
Lodge and a Royal Arch Chapter. 


In Mark Lodges, under the jurisdiction of the United Grand Lodge of Mark Master 
Masons of Victoria, it is customary to present a “penny” to the candidate on his 
advancement. A record of all “Marks” is kept in a Mark Lodge and returned for 
registration to the Grand Secretary of the Grand Lodge. 


It is customary for each Lodge of Mark Master Masons to adopt some suitable device for 
its members generally, alterable in some way for each individual (Fig. 13). 


The equilateral triangle, however, is excepted and not allowed to be used except by the 
Worshipful Master as referred to in a portion of the ceremony. (G. L. Marquand, Grand 
Scribe E.) 


Washington. - Selection of Mark. Sec. 77. It is not proper to adopt a resolution in a chapter 
to suspend the advancement of a Brother Mark Master to the higher degrees until he has 
selected his Mark, if properly reminded to do so by the Secretary, whose duty it is to see 
that it is done, and who should be disciplined for neglecting to perform this duty. For 
refusal to record his Mark, the Brother may be disciplined by the chapter. (Code, Sec. 72, 
P- 24.) 


Wyoming. - Sec. 87. No candidate shall be exalted to the degree of Royal Arch Mason 
until he shall have chosen his Mark and the same has been recorded, and every constituent 
chapter is required to keep a proper Book of Marks in which shall be recorded the Mark of 
each and all its members. (Con., Sec. 87.) 


(To be continued.) 



EDITORIAL 


A PHILOSOPHY OP INDUSTRY 


PHILOSOPHY of Industry deals with general principles and not with the technique of 
industrial organization or with programs of social reform. Questions of social reform fall 
within the province of sociology and matters pertaining to the forms of industrial 
organization belong to economics. We are concerned herewith only with the aims and 
puiposes of industry considered as a whole. Industry as it actually exists can not be 
subsumed under a single generalization; it is too complex, too vast, even, to be grasped by 
the mired as a single whole; but just as there are general laws threading the infinite 
complexities of nature so are there general principles running through industry, and it is 
these general principles which constitute the problem and the substance of a Philosophy of 
Industry. 


Eighteenth century thought laid down as its most fundamental law of industry the doctrine 
of private right, and the corollary of the sanctity of private contracts. Actual experience has 
disproved this assumption because it has shown that it offers us no remedy when private 
rights conflict with social welfare. Private rights must be secured by any philosophy of the 
matter but a philosophy of industry must have a more comprehensive grasp. 


Karl Marx and his followers have translated the whole matter into the terms of a class 
struggle. The owners of industry and the workers are engaged in a struggle for dominance 
of the industrial processes. Such a struggle, no doubt, does exist, but this fact does not 
comprise an industrial philosophy. How is society as a whole to arbitrate this struggle? By 
what criterion is it to determine when this struggle has eventuated in a satisfactory form of 
industry? In the hands of the workers industry may be so organized as to fail to fulfil the 
functions of an industrial system; and vice versa. 


Lor the same reason the present essay throws out of court all forms of a priori programs for 
industrial reorganization; these programs can not in themselves constitute a true 



philosophy of industry because we need a criterion whereby to test whether or not any 
given program is efficient for the needs of society. 


The thesis of the present paper can be stated in few words: 


Human society consists of actual men, women and children who have certain actual 
needs, such as for food, clothing, fuel, shelter, education, recreation, and opportunity to 
earn a livelihood. An industrial system is judged by whether or not it succeeds in 
satisfying these needs. All questions having to do with matters of ownership, 
management, control, etc., are secondary to this function, and are to be judged by 
whether or not they enable industry to do that which society can rightly demand that it 
do. 


One may form a mental picture of this simple thesis. On the one hand are the millions of 
men, women, and children whose needs are to be served; on the other hand are the natural 
resources wherefrom the materials are to be drawn which alone can satisfy these needs; the 
industrial system stands between the people and the materials, and its function is to secure, 
to prepare, and to distribute the latter. It is a just, efficient, and successful system exactly 
in proportion as it achieves this end. 


To illustrate. The people of the United States need a certain quantity of meat; the sources 
of supply are found in the great herds that feed upon the plains; it is the function of the 
meat industry to see that these herds are transformed into useable units and delivered to the 
points of need at the least possible expense. If the meat industry fails of fulfilling this 
function it must be reorganized. 


The needs of society are prior to all private interests. If any given unit of industry fails of 
its function it must be reorganized though that should conflict with the interests of some 
one man or of a group of men. 



In seeking to satisfy the needs of men, women, and children industry must necessarily 
adjust itself to the factors in the case, and these factors must be taken into consideration in 
this connection. Of these we may speak of 


I. THE HUMAN FACTORS 


Industry is not a system apart from society; it is society itself at work to satisfy its own 
needs; accordingly, it is necessary for industry continually to seek to adjust itself as closely 
as possible to the plain and unchangeable realities of human nature. These are the human 
factors in industry and they may be described as follows: 


(a) Man is by nature a social being; no form of industry can therefore be tolerated which 
tends to disrupt the social bonds. Among these bonds are those that link husband and wife, 
parents and children, etc. Also, the essential social institutions, such as the home, the 
church, the school, etc., must evermore be safeguarded. 


(b) Man has by nature many interests other than industrial, such as, for example, 
amusements, politics, religion, etc., and industry must as far as possible be held in mutual 
organization with these. 


(c) Man has an indestructible instinct for possession, therefore industry must make it 
possible for an individual to own property; but this does not indicate just what kind of 
property it is possible for man to own. 


(d) Man has within himself, as an inalienable part of his nature, an instinct for contrivance, 
for invention, etc.; if this instinct is suppressed beyond a certain limit his nature is 
mutilated and he is rendered unhappy. 



(e) Man has within himself an equally inalienable instinct for private freedom. Any form 
of enforced servitude is impossible. 


(f) Man's body is susceptible to external conditions; he can not long work under 
unhealthful conditions. 


(g) Industry has become in nature a complicated process; therefore the individual who is 
efficiently to perform his own particular functions therein must be educated, and has a 
right to such education. 


(h) Man's capacity of readjustment to new environmental conditions is limited and all 
changes in industrial methods must be adjusted thereto. This fact renders dangerous all 
schemes for a sudden revolution in industrial methods. 


These human factors are not here thought of in the terms of private and individual rights 
but in the terms of concrete fact. Just as the organization of a living animal is adjusted to 
the realities in its own particular environment so must industry be adjusted to the realities 
of human nature. 


II. THE NATURAL FACTORS 


Many idealists, in their demands for a complete reorganization of industry, overlook 
industrial limitations which are inherent in nature itself. Coal lies underground and must 
be mined; if we are to have coal, men must work subterraneously. Farm products grow in 
the soil and men must plow, and sow, and reap if they are to harvest the same. Fish live in 
water; lumber exists in forest, often difficult of access; oil must be drilled for, etc., etc. 
Industry can not escape the forms imposed upon it by these natural factors and society can 
not expect it to. 



III. THE FACTORS OF INSTRUMENT AFITY 


Industry by its very nature must be carried on by tools, machines, and other mechanical 
contrivances and instrumentalities. 


(a) Industry is under obligation to develop its mechanical agencies as efficiently as 
possible in order that society be served with the least possible expenditure of energy; 


(b) And society can not reasonably demand of industry such a degree of efficiency as 
mechanical art can not make possible. 


IV. THE FACTORS OF CHANGE 


Industry must be so organized as to be capable of readjustment to change 


(a) New devices may at any time be invented; 


(b) New natural resources may be discovered; 


(c) Man himself may develop new needs and wants; 


(d) Old resources, devices, or wants may fail. 



For these, and similar reasons, there is an element of the unpredictable in industry, and in 
human society; therefore no given program of industry can remain fixed, nor can any such 
program be imposed upon the future. 


It is not possible for society at large dogmatically to dictate what form industry must take 
at any given point of time or space; the function to be fulfilled in any given event, and the 
factors whereto it is necessary to make adjustment, must always determine what is the 
most satisfactory form of ownership, management, control, etc., etc. 


In just what manner any given industry must organize itself in order to harmonize with the 
various factors as above described, and in order to satisfy the needs as above indicated, is 
always a problem for the economist. H. L. Haywood. 


THE LIBRARY 


EDITED BY BRO. ROBERT TIPTON 


The object of this Department is to acquaint our readers with time-tried Masonic books not 
always familiar; with the best Masonic literature now being published; and with such non- 
Masonic books as may especially appeal to Masons. The Library Editor will be very glad 
to render any possible assistance to studious individuals or to study clubs and lodges, 
either through this Department or by personal correspondence. 


It will be our aim to publish in this Department each month a list of such publications as 
we may be able from time to time to secure for members of the Society. However, a book 
listed herein this month may be out of stock next month, and further copies unobtainable, 
and for this reason it is recommended that when ordering books or pamphlets from these 
lists the latest monthly issue of TE1E BUILDER be consulted, and no orders be made from 
lists more than thirty days old. 



In the monthly reviews the names and addresses of the publishers of the books are given in 
order that our readers may order such books direct from the publishers instead of through 
the Society. In many instances the books may be found in stock at local book stores. 


PSYCHICAL RESEARCH 


“Psychical Research,” by Dr. John S. King. Published by the James A. McCann Co., 
New York, N. Y. Price $4.00. 


DURING the period of the War we were seriously confronted with the question, Is there 
Life after Death? The unparalleled onslaught upon human life severing from the world so 
many of those who promised so much naturally induced fresh speculation on the question 
of Immortality. 


In the early days of the War we were told of the vast congregations which thronged the 
churches in belligerent countries. Then, a little later, we were told that a fatalistic attitude 
had become characteristic of the vast number, and with the acceptance of the doctrine of 
fatalism there came a visible decline in church attendance. Since the signing of the 
Armistice this attendance has become almost negligible. 


That the question of Immortality abides, persistently challenging the thoughts of men, is 
due, we believe, less to the voice of the church than to those who hitherto but shared the 
contempt of the church, namely, the spiritualists, and those dubbed scientific researchers in 
psychical phenomena. 


It will be noted that those engaged in scientific research have been regarded with a greater 
degree of toleration than the spiritualists. To our mind, however, there is but little 
difference between the two, inasmuch as it seems that every investigator of psychical 



phenomena gains a conviction of possible communication and contact with disembodied 
spirits, thus proving beyond any doubt, as they readily assert, that Immortality is a fact. 


While admitting the existence of frauds and deceptive practices in connection with 
occasional spiritualistic seances, the burden of the conviction lies in the possibility of 
communion between this and the spirits life. We are ready to admit that the books 
dealing with the matter are practically all written in the same vein, and we feel that when 
one has read the discoveries of such men as Professor Hyslop or Sir William Crooks, he 
has grasped in substance what others have said or are saying. The evidences are much 
alike in character, and the modes of obtaining contact of but little variation. 


However, an occasional book is brought forth which possesses a freshness of presentation, 
and such a book coming from a distinguished personage ought to merit our respect. Dr. 
John S. King, the President of the Canadian Psychical Research Society, is the latest 
contributor to this fiefd. We thoroughly enjoyed the chapters wherein Dr. King is the great 
apologist for his position. Rarely have we read anything so fair in its appeal for a 
reasonable and impartial consideration of a much mooted question. His work is so 
readably written that its perusal at once imparts both knowledge and charm. 


But few readers, perhaps, would care to peruse the mass of evidences submitted, but the 
chapters dealing with seances in which the materialization of departed people take place, 
will not fail to attract and hold the attention. The interest in what was so absorbing a topic 
during the war has waned, but the time for sane estimates of such important subjects is not 
when the sorrows encompass us, but at a time which admits of calm and dispassionate 
reflection. To those desiring an easy and authoritative introduction to the subject we 
recommend this work of Dr. King. 


* * * 


’’The Road to En-Dor,” by E. H. Jones, Lieutenant I. A. R. O. Published by the John 
Lane Co., 1 16-120 West 32nd St., New York, N. Y. Price $2.00. 



After our introduction to the book on psychical research by Dr. John S. King, we will let 
the foreword of this work bespeak its own contents. 


This book, besides being an extraordinary story, will especially appeal to everyone who is 
interested in spiritualism. It tells in minute and exact detail how two young British officers 
who previously knew nothing of the subject took up spiritualism originally to amuse their 
fellow-prisoners in a Turkish prison camp; how they afterwards convinced not only the 
Turkish officers of their mediumistic powers, but even their fellow officers; how 
eventually the “spook” ran the camp, securing many privileges for the inmates, and finally 
nearly effected the escape of the two mediums and kidnapped the Turkish commandant 
and interpreter. 


Afterwards the two officers feigned madness so effectually that they were repatriated on 
compassionate grounds as insane, and later had some difficulty in convincing the British 
authorities of their sanity. 


The book reads like a wild romance, but is authenticated in every detail by fellow-officers 
and official documents. The Turkish governor was actually courtmartialled for his part in a 
treasure hunt instituted by the “spook,” and since the Armistice the authors have received 
letters from Turkish officials asking them to return and persist in the search for the hidden 
treasure. 


* * * 


A COLLECTION OF GOVERNOR COOLIDGE’S ADDRESSES 


“Have Faith in Massachusetts,” by Governor Calvin Coolidge. Published by The 
Eloughton, Mifflin Company, 16 East 40th Street, New York, N. Y. 



“Let every inhabitant make known his determination to support law and order.” In these 
few words Calvin Coolidge, the man and citizen, is seen as he reveals himself in this 
collection of addresses arranged under the above title. That we have a clear thinker is at 
once evidenced. His world perspective is not of the yesterday or tomorrow, but concerns 
the today. He clearly distinguishes the necessity of putting the house in order before the 
things of the morrow can be rightly undertaken. Do the day's work, whatever comes, and 
do it with reference to right and justice, the fundamental principles on which this country 
was founded. Some of the addresses sound academically cultural, but none of them are 
void of those crisp epigrammatic sayings that go right to the heart of things. There is a 
fearless arraignment of demagoguery and an expression for a firm, broad, deep faith in 
man, and a passionate appeal for its realization, as upon this platform alone can the 
righteousness that endures be established. 


NOVEMBER BOOK LIST 


The following list embraces practically all the standard works on Masonry which we are 
able to secure and keep in stock for the accommodation of individual members of the 
Society, Study Clubs and Lodges. 


We are finding it more difficult each year to procure new or second-hand copies of the 
earlier works on Masonry of which, owing to the limited market for them at the time of 
their publication, but a small number of copies were printed. 


We are continually in search for additional items which will be listed in this column 
whenever it is our good fortune to secure them. 


It is suggested that the latest list be consulted before sending in orders and that no orders 
be made from lists more than one month old, since our stock of these books is limited and 
a book listed this month may be out of stock by the time next month's list is published. 



Since the publishers are constantly increasing their prices to us the following prices are 
subject to such changes. 


PUBLICATIONS ISSUED BY THE SOCIETY 


1915 

bound volume of THE BUILDER 

$3.75 

1916 

bound volume of THE BUILDER 

3.75 

1917 

bound volume of THE BUILDER 

3.75 

1918 

bound volume of THE BUILDER 

3.75 

1919 

bound volume of THE BUILDER 

3.75 


Philosophy of Freemasonry, Pound 1 .25 

Freemasonry in America Prior to 1750, Melvin M. Johnson, P.G.M., Massachusetts 1.35 

1722 Constitutions ( reproduced by photographic plates from an original copy in the 
archives of the Iowa Masonic Library, Cedar Rapids). Edition limited, 2.00 

"The Story of Old Glory, The Oldest Flag," Bro. J. W. Barry, P. G. M., Iowa, red buffing 
binding, gilt lettering, illustrated. A story of the Flag and Masonry, 1 .25 

"The Story of Old Glory, The Oldest Flag," paper covers .50 

"Further Notes on the Comacine Masters," W. Ravenscroft, England. A sequel to "The 
Comacines, Their Predecessors and Their Successors," a Masonic digest of Leader 
Scott's book "The Cathedral Builders" and containing the latest researches of Brother 
Ravenscroft which present a very logical argument for the connection of Freemasonry of 
the present day with the Roman Collegia and traveling Masons of the early times, paper 
covers, illustrated .50 

Symbolism of the First Degree, Gage, pamphlet .15 



Symbolism of the Third Degree, Ball, pamphlet . 1 5 

Symbolism of the Three Degrees, Street, 68 pages, paper covers. The lessons and 
symbols of each degree traced to their origin, in every instance that it has been possible 
to so trace them. Brother Street gives many explanations of our symbols in this little 
book on which our monitors but vaguely touch .35 

Deeper Aspects of Masonic Symbolism, Waite, pamphlet . 1 5 

“what an Entered Apprentice Ought to Know,” by Hal Riviere. (Special prices on lot 
orders for 25 or more copies for presentation purposes.) Pamplet, paper covers . 1 5 


* * * 


PUBLICATIONS FROM OTHER SOURCES IN IN STOCK AT ANAMOSA 


"The Builders," a Story and Study of Masonry, by Brother Joseph Fort Newton, formerly 
Editor-in-Chief of THE BUILDER $1.75* 


Mackey's Encyclopaedia, 1919 edition, in two volumes, Black Fabrikoid binding 
16.00 

Symbolism of Freemasonry, A. G. Mackey 3.15 
Masonic Jurisprudence, A. G. Mackey 3.15 
Masonic Parliamentary Law, A. G. Mackey 2.65 

“Freemasonry Before the existance of Grand Lodges,” Lionel Vibert. A digest of the 
researches of Gould, Hughan, Rylands, Speth and others on the origin and early history 
of Masonry 1.75 

Concise History of Freemasonry, Robert Freke Gould 4.50 
Collected Essays on Freemasonry, Gould 7.00 



* * * 


The foregoing prices include postage and insurance or registration fee on all items except 
pamphlets. The latter will be sent by regular mail not insured or registered. 




Every man is a missionary, now and forever, for good or for evil, whether he intends or 
designs it not. - Chalmers 


THE QUESTION BOX 


THE BUILDER is an open forum for free and fraternal discussion. Each of its contributors 
writes under his own name, and is responsible for his own opinions. Believing that a unity 
of spirit is better than a uniformity of opinion, the Research Society, as such, does not 
champion any one school of Masonic thought as over against another, but offers to all 
alike a medium for fellowship and instruction, leaving each to stand or fall by its own 
merits. 


The Question Box and Correspondence Column are open to all members of the Society at 
all times. Questions of any nature on Masonic subjects are earnestly invited from our 
members, particularly those connected with lodges or study clubs which are following our 
"Bulletin Course of Masonic Study." When requested, questions will be answered 
promptly by mail before publication in this department. 


MASONIC STATUS OF PRESIDENTIAL AND VICE PRESIDENTIAL 
CANDIDATES 



Will you please tell me, through the Question Box Department of THE BUILDER, 
whether or not the Presidential and Vice-Presidential candidates are Masons ? 

H.G.F., Nebraska. 


Senator Warren G. Harding is a Master Mason in good standing in Marion Lodge No. 70, 
Marion, Ohio. 


Governor Cox is a Master Mason in good standing in Jefferson Lodge No. 90, 
Middletown, Ohio. 


Franklin D. Roosevelt is a Master Mason in good standing in Holland Lodge No. 8, New 
York, N. Y. 


Governor Coolidge is not a member of the Masonic fraternity. He and his family are 
attendants at a Congregational Church in Northampton. Massachusetts. 


* * * 


THE NATIONAL LEAGUE OF MASONIC CLUBS 


Can you give me any information concerning the “National League of Masonic Clubs” 
that recently held their Annual Convention in New York City ? C. H. B., Rhode Island. 



The “National League of Masonic Clubs” is a national association comprising at the 
present time 240 Masonic Clubs located in twenty-seven Grand Jurisdictions. 


In March, 1905, Brother S. R. Clute, Secretary of the Masonic Temple Club of Syracuse, 
New York, with the consent and co-operation of his Club, decided to send out a call to the 
Masonic Clubs then in existence in New York State asking them to send representatives to 
a meeting in Syracuse to consider the advisability of working out a plan to provide for the 
interchange of courtesies to Visiting members of Masonic Clubs in the State. Pursuant to 
this call there assembled at Syracuse, New York, on April 20, 1905, in the rooms of the 
Masonic Temple Club, representatives from the following Clubs: 


Masonic Temple Club, Syracuse, New York. 

Masonic Club, New York, N. Y. 

Masonic Club, Auburn, New York. 

Oswego Masonic Club, Oswego, New York. 

Representatives from Herkimer Lodge No. 432, Herkimer, N. Y. 


A discussion followed upon general measures for increasing good fellowship among the 
various Masonic Clubs of the State, and there was adopted a form of traveling card to 
enable its possessor to secure Masonic Club privileges, not only in his own Club, but 
throughout the State. The following resolutions were adopted: 


Resolved: That we, the representatives of the Masonic Clubs of Syracuse, New York City, 
Rochester, Oswego, Herkimer and Auburn, do hereby constitute an organization to be 
known as “The League of Masonic Clubs,” with headquarters at Syracuse, and that we 
meet annually on the third Thursday in April, with the Masonic Temple Club of Syracuse. 



Resolved: That the purpose of this League shall be the promotion of fraternal relations 
between the Masonic Clubs comprising it and to facilitate the interchange of courtesies to 
visiting members. 


Resolved: That it is the sense of this organization that the several clubs forming this 
League may issue, to members in good standing, traveling cards signed by the Secretaries 
of the Clubs and countersigned by the members to whom they are issued, and entitling said 
members to the courtesies of the Clubs comprising the League for a period not to exceed 
six months from the date of issue - the foregoing, however, subject to ratification by the 
Clubs forming the League. 


Annual Conventions of the League have been held as follows: 


First Annual Convention. - Held at the Masonic Temple Club, Syracuse, N. Y., April 19, 
1906. Representatives were present from many Clubs throughout the State. It was at this 
Convention that the name of the organization was changed to “The National League of 
Masonic Clubs,” that the League might branch out and include Clubs other than those in 
New York State. President, S. R. Clute, Syracuse; Secretary-Treasurer, F. D. Clark, 
Oswego. 


Second Annual Convention. - Held at the Masonic Temple Club, Syracuse, N. Y., April 
18, 1907. League Constitution and By-Laws were adopted at this meeting. President, S. R. 
Clute, Syracuse; Secretary-Treasurer, F. D. Clark, Oswego. 


Third Annual Convention. - Held at the Masonic Club, Rochester, N Y., April 16, 1908. 
President, Andrew Ludolph, Rochester; Secretary-Treasurer, W. H. Homibrook, Fulton, 
N. Y. 



Fourth Annual Convention. - Held at the Masonic Temple, Troy, N. Y., April 15, 1909. 
President, Eugene Bryan, Troy, N. Y.; Secretary-Treasurer, W. H. Hornibrook, Fulton, N. 
Y. 


Fifth Annual Convention. - Held at the Acacia Club, Buffalo, N. Y., April 21, 1910. 
President, Albert Barber, Buffalo, N. Y.; Secretary-Treasurer, W. H. Hornibrook, Fulton, 
N. Y. 


Sixth Annual Convention. - Held at the Masonic Club, Brooklyn, N. Y., April 20, 191 1. At 
this Convention a League sign was adopted and arrangements made to have a sign sent to 
every Club in the League. President, Francis G. Coates, Brooklyn, N. Y.; Secretary- 
Treasurer, W. H. Hornibrook, Fulton, N.Y. 


Seventh Annual Convention. - Held at the Masonic Temple, Herkimer, N. Y., April 18, 
1912. President, Arthur H. Smith, Herkimer, N. Y.; Secretary-Treasurer, W. H. 
Hornibrook, Fulton, N. Y. 


Eighth Annual Convention. - Held at the Masonic Temple, Reading, Pa., April 17, 1913. 
President, Francis F. Seidel, Reading, Pa.; Secretary-Treasurer, W. H. Hornibrook, Fulton, 
N. Y. 


Ninth Annual Convention. - Held at the Masonic Temple, Ithaca, N. Y., April 16, 1914. At 
this gathering Brother Joseph F. Lance, member of the Acacia Club, Buffalo, was elected 
Emeritus Past President. President, J. Warren Georgia, Ithaca, N. Y.; Secretary-Treasurer, 
W. H. Hornibrook, Fulton, N. Y. 


Tenth Annual Convention. - Held at the Masonic Temple, Glens Falls, N. Y., May 13, 
1915. President, Chas. N. Van Trump, Glens Falls, N. Y.; Secretary-Treasurer, W. H. 
Hornibrook, Fulton, N. Y. 



Eleventh Annual Convention. - Held at Hiram Lodge No. 1, A. F. & A. M., New Haven, 
Conn., May 1 1,1916. A seal of the League was adopted at this meeting and provision was 
also made to publish a quarterly bulletin. President, Charles D. Eggleston, New Haven, 
Conn.; Secretary-Treasurer, W. H. Homibrook, Fulton, N. Y. 


Twelfth Annual Convention. - Held at Pittsburgh, Pa., May 9-10, 1917. President, George 
P. Kountz, Pittsburgh, Pa.; Vice President, Robert I. Clegg, Cleveland, Ohio; Secretary- 
Treasurer, Joseph T. Slingsby, Rutherford, N. J. At this meeting plans were gone into very 
thoroughly with a view to furthering the interests of the League and in arranging the 
official line-up for general progress, and the appointment of Deputy Vice-Presidents all 
over the country 


Thirteenth Annual Convention. - Held at Buffalo, N. Y., June 10-11, 1918. President, 
Robert I. Clegg, Cleveland, Ohio; Vice President, Jesse I. Penney, Ingram, Pa.; Secretary- 
Treasurer, A. G. Pitts, Detroit, Mich. 


Fourteenth Annual Convention. - Held at Detroit, Mich., June 18-19, 1919. President, 
Jesse I. Penney, Ingram, Pa.; Vice President, Joseph T. Slingsby, Rutherford, N. J.; 
SecretaryTreasurer, A. G. Pitts, Detroit, Mich. 


The membership has grown as indicated in the following table: 


Year 

Clubs in League 

Year 

Clubs in Lea 

1905 

7 

1913 

62 

1906 

....19 

1914 

77 

1907 

25 

1915 

92 

1908 

26 

1916 

113 



1909 

35 

1917 

134 

1910 

36 

1918 

157 

1911 

43 

1919 

169 

1912 

52 

1920 

240 


The Fifteenth Annual Convention of the League was held in New York City, July 6, 7 
and 8, 1920. The business of the Convention was largely of the routine affairs of the 
League, though it went outside of this in adopting resolutions condemning the 
government of Hungary for having barred Masonry. The resolution reads: 


Whereas, It has been brought to the attention of the National League of Masonic Clubs 
that the present government of Hungary has recently barred Masonic gatherings or 
conventions of Masonic lodges within her borders, be it , 


Resolved, That the National League of Masonic Clubs of America, in annual convention 
assembled, register a fervent protest against this drastic and unseemly action as 
unbecoming a free and untrammeled people and as being against the promotion of 
fraternity and brotherly love which was the star of hope followed by all civilized peoples 
in the World War, and 


That this resolution be embodied in the proceedings of this Convention and a copy sent to 
all Clubs associated with the League. 


The new President of the League is Brother Joseph T. Slingsby, of Rutherford, N. J. The 
next Annual Convention will be held in Washington, D. C., in May, 1921. 


* * * 



MASONIC PLAYS WANTED 


In the San Francisco Masonic bodies we have a Dramatic Club, known as the “Square and 
Compass Players.” We have already produced “The Eighteenth Century Lodge,” “The 
Legend of the Temple” and “The Traitor.” 


We are always on the lookout for something new, and the thought has just occurred to me 
that perhaps you might know of something along this line. J. M. W., California. 


We regret that we do not know of any Masonic dramas that might be added to this list. 
Perhaps some of our readers can help us out. 


— o- 


CORRESPONDENCE 


THE KNIGHTS OF RHODES 


George Sandys, poet, traveller, and gallant cavalier, was one of the earliest to embark on 
foreign travel, and write a description of his journey. He started out in August, 1610, and 
returned apparently in 1612. The volume relating his “Travailes” was published shortly 
after and among the many interesting contents is the following account of the Origin of the 
Knights of Rhodes, which will be read with interest by not a few readers of THE 
BUILDER. 



The story runs: This Order of Knighthood received their denomination from John, the 
charitable patriarch of Alexandria, though vowed, to St. John the Baptist as their patron. 
Their first seat was the Hospital of St. John in Jerusalem (whereupon they were called 
Knights Hospitallers), built by one Gerrard by such time as the Holy Land became famous 
by the successful expeditions of the Christians; who drew divers worthy persons into that 
society, approved by Pope Gelasius the second. They, by the alliance of Honorius the 
second, wore garments of black signed with a white cross. Raymond, the first master of 
the Order, did amplifie their canons, instilling himself “The poor servant of Christ and 
Guardian of the Hospital in Jerusalem.” In every country throughout Christendom they 
had hospitals and revenues assigned them with contributions procured by Pope Innocent 
the second. They were tyed by their vows to entertain all pilgrims with singular humanity; 
to safeguard their passages from thieves and incursions, and voluntarily to sacrifice their 
lives in defence of that country. 


The ceremonies used in Knighting are these: First, carrying in his hand a taper of white 
wax, he kneeleth before the altar, clothed in a long, loose garment, and desireth the order 
of the ordinary. Then in the Name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, he receiveth 
the sword therewith to defend the Catholic Church, to rel ulse and vanquish the enemy, to 
relieve the oppressed, if need be to expose himself unto death for the faith, and all by the 
power of the Cross, which by the sword hilt is defigured. Then is he girt with a belt and 
thrice strook on the shoulders with his sword to put him in mind that for the honour of 
Christ he is cheerfully to suffer whatever is grievous; who, taking it of him there 
flourisheth it aloft as a provokement to the adversary, and so sheaths it again, having 
wiped it first on his arm to testify that henceforth he will live undefiledly. Then he that 
gives him knighthood, laying his hand on his shoulder, doth exhort him to be vigilant in 
the faith and to aspire unto true honour by courageous and laudable actions, etc. Which 
done, the Knights do put on his spurs, gilt, to signifie that he should spurn gold as dirt, not 
to do what was ignoble for reward. And so goes he to Mass with a taper in his hand; the 
works of piety, hospitality, and redemption of captives being commended unto him; told 
also of what he was to perform in regard of his Order. 


Then is asked if he be a freeman, if not joined in matrimony, if under vow to another 
order, or not of any profession; and if he be resolved to live among them, to revenge their 
injuries and quit the authority of secular magistrate ? Having answered thereunto, upon 
receipt of the Sacrament, he vows in this Order: “I vow to the Almighty God, to the Virgin 
Mary, His Immaculate Mother, and to St. John the Baptist, perpetually by the help of God, 
to be truly obedient to all my superiors appointed by God and this Order to live without 
anything of mine own and withall to live chastly.” Whereupon he is made a partaker of 



their privileges and indulgences granted unto them by the see of Rome. Dudley Wright, 
England. 

FAITH AND HOPE 

BY BRO. GERALD A. NANC ARROW, INDIANA 

Far down the endless flood of years 
There stands a bold majestic isle, 

Where hearts aweary cease their tears 
And aching souls find rest awhile. 

And on the headlands of this Rock 
A blazing beacon never tires 
Our deep and welling fears to lock, 

And feed our dying spirit fires. 

As to us in an endless wave 

Its swelling beams illume the way, 

We tread anew the checkered pave 



And all our journeyings are gay.